Monday, May 25, 2020

1) Indonesia's unconscionable prisoner policy

2) Police Hunt Down Shooter of COVID-19 Task Force Members in Papua 
3) PNG health authorities worried about Covid-19 situation in West Papua
----------------------------

1) Indonesia's unconscionable prisoner policy 
Usman Hamid and Veronica Koman

Jakarta   /   Mon, May 25, 2020   /   04:23 pm
The United Nations is right: It’s impossible to practice physical distancing and self-isolation in an overcrowded prison. We therefore applaud the decision by Law and Human Rights Minister Yasonna Laoly to release almost 40,000 prisoners at risk from the COVID-19 pandemic.
As this devastating virus sweeps across the globe, prisons are at risk of becoming a very dangerous hotspot for COVID-19 outbreaks. Minister Yasonna’s policy however falls crucially short: Prisoners of conscience are excluded from the policy, despite the UN urging that “political prisoners should be among the first released”.
It is more important than ever that states take urgent measures to protect all those who are deprived of their liberty, especially by releasing all individuals who are held simply for peacefully exercising their rights.
President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo’s government has detained 69 prisoners of conscience (PoCs) on treason charges, a record in recent times for Indonesia. The majority of them, 54, are indigenous Papuans. Five of the PoCs will be released Tuesday after completing their jail terms. 
One Indonesian of Batak ethnicity, Paulus Suryanta Ginting, is the first non-indigenous West Papuan to be charged with treason over the self-determination cause. Meanwhile, a Polish man, Jakub Skrzypski, is the first foreign national to be charged with treason under Indonesian law and has been recognized by the European Parliament as a political prisoner. His “crime” was having met with pro-independence Papuan activists while traveling. The 12 other PoCs are from Maluku.
All are peaceful activists who have been detained for political expression -- simply carrying flags, or organizing or participating in peaceful protests, or being members of political organizations. Eleven of them have been sentenced, 15 are on trial, and 40 others are awaiting trial. No one should ever be arrested or detained solely for exercising their human rights.
The majority of these PoCs, 54 people, were arrested during and in the immediate wake of the 2019 West Papua uprising that took place from Aug. 19 to Sept. 23 last year. These protests against racism and for self-determination, likened to an “earthquake” of anger and hope, took place in towns and villages throughout Papua. Demonstrations of solidarity broke out in cites all over Indonesia too, and garnered international attention for the Papuan situation.
Jakarta’s response was a crackdown so brutal that the UN human rights office issued not one but two statements of concern. Authorities made a series of mass arrests ahead of further protests on the Dec 1, 2019, when Papuans commemorate their national day.
By the end of the uprising, more than 10,000 extra police and military had been deployed to Papua. Armed paramilitary police patrolled universities and residential areas. No further public gatherings were allowed in the province. Self-determination protests have since abated, because almost all student leaders and key leaders of Papua’s civil movement were either detained or forced into hiding.
There are at least seven prominent PoCs currently on trial in Balikpapan, East Kalimantan. Two of them, Buchtar Tabuni and Stevanus Itlay, are imprisoned for their political activities for the third time. On Oct. 4 last year, they were transferred, in breach of criminal procedures law and without prior notice to their lawyers and families, from Papua to Kalimantan for “security reasons”. The defendants have been questioned in court as to who had shouted “Free West Papua” slogans and who had brought Morning Star flags to the protests. Their hearings, held online as the pandemic rages, showed they are on trial for expressing their political beliefs.
On May 11, the four PoCs in Jakarta were almost released by prison authorities implementing the COVID-19 safety policy, as more than two-thirds of their sentences had been served. All four had signed release letters confirming their assimilation, had tested negative for COVID-19 and were holding a package of rice and instant noodles to take home. As they awaited the door to freedom, a prison staffer arrived and apologized; a political decision had come from above canceling their release.
One can only imagine the mental anguish not only for the prisoners but also their families, arising from this cruel move by the Indonesian government to quash their release.
The PoCs are detained in different prisons and detention centers. Conditions vary, but they are all characterized by overcrowding, poor sanitation and extremely limited healthcare services. The government has been criticized for its COVID-19 handling.
Prisoners of conscience have not committed any crime and yet they continue to be arbitrarily detained, in conditions that are now becoming increasingly dangerous.  
As a sitting member of the UN Human Rights Council, Indonesia needs to respect international human rights law by releasing these prisoners of conscience immediately and unconditionally.
***
Usman Hamid is the director of Amnesty International Indonesia. Veronica Koman is a human rights lawyer representing 63 prisoners of conscience under the UN special procedures.
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not reflect the official stance of The Jakarta Post.
———————————————————


2) Police Hunt Down Shooter of COVID-19 Task Force Members in Papua 
Translator: TEMPO 
Editor: Markus Wisnu Murti 
25 May 2020 11:22 WIB
TEMPO.COJakarta - The government’s Nemangkawi Operation Task Unit is still hunting down the armed group that shot two members of the COVID-19 Task Force in Papua. One of the task force members was killed.
The Nemangkawi Operation Task Unit reported the incident occurred in Wandai district, Intan Jaya regency, Papua, Friday, May 22, 2020, at around 16:30 local time.
The attacked health workers were Amalek Bagau, 30 years old, and Eniko Somou, 39 years old. “They were shot while delivering medicines to avert the spread of COVID-19 in Intan Jaya regency,” the Namangkawi Operation Task Unit said in a written statement on Friday, May 22, 2020.
Personnel of the task unit and the Intan Jaya Police evacuated the victims to Nabire by Smart Air aircraft from the Sugapa Airport, Intan Jaya regency.
The plane touched down at the Douw Aturure Nabire Airport on Saturday, May 23, 2020, at 10:20 local time and the victims were rushed to the Nabire Regional General Hospital (RSUD) at 10:30 local time for further treatment.
Papua Police spokesman Sr. Comr. A.M. Kamal said one of the victims passed away while the other was in critical condition. He said the remoteness and the hard terrain of the crime scene were among the difficulties security personnel must face to reach the location.
“It took us around five hours to get to the crime scene,” Kamal said, adding that the COVID-19 pandemic had exacerbated the situation.
 
ANTARA

----------------------------------


3) PNG health authorities worried about Covid-19 situation in West Papua
about 1 hour ago  

Papua New Guinea's acting Secretary of Health says the daily increase of Covid-19 cases in West Papua poses a great threat to his country.
The Papua Region of Indonesia has seen at least 65 new cases of the coronavirus over the past 36 hours bringing a total to some 686 confirmed cases.
Paison Dakulala, who is also the State of Emergency Deputy Controller, said the alarming increase means that PNG is still in the danger zone as far as the virus and its people must not be complacent.
"With the increase in the number of COVID-19 cases in West Papua, the PNG Government is revisiting its strategies along the Western border with Indonesia," Paison Dakulala said.
"To ensure that the movement of people across the border is tightened to simply avoid possible transmission of COVID-19 in PNG," Dr Dakulala said.
"To date, there are no deaths in the country and therefore our Health team and the security forces are on the ground ensuring that this COVID-19 transmission must not take place," he said.

At this stage, PNG had only eight confirmed cases of Covid-19, the last case was reported about a month ago. All eight have recovered.
As of this week over 31,000 inbound passengers has been screened at the international airport and seaport in Port Moresby.
More than 8,500 travellers has been being monitored by health surveillance teams.
----------------

Sunday, May 24, 2020

1) OPM says TNI, police shot medical workers in Papua


2) Papuan armed group accused of shooting COVID-19 team members
----------------------------------------------


https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2020/05/24/opm-says-tni-police-shot-medical-workers-in-papua.html

1) OPM says TNI, police shot medical workers in Papua
News Desk 
The Jakarta Post  Jakarta   /   Sun, May 24, 2020   /   07:11 pm

The Free Papua Movement (OPM) has denied that it was involved in the shooting of two members of the Intan Jaya regency COVID-19 task force, claiming that the two men were shot by security forces. 
“We want to emphasize that the people who shot the two medical workers were TNI [Indonesian Military] and National Police personnel. They are the culprits,” OPM spokesperson Sebby Sanbom said in a statement on Saturday, as quoted by tempo.co. “Indonesia must take responsibility.”
The two medical workers – identified as Amalek Bagau, 30, and Eniko Somou, 39 – were reportedly shot while delivering medical supplies to a remote area in Intan Jaya regency at about 4:30 p.m. local time on Friday.
Security forces said they evacuated the two men and transferred them to the Nabire General Hospital on Saturday morning. Amalek remains in critical condition, and Eniko has died from his wounds.
Military and police personnel belonging to the Nemangkawi task force have said they are on a manhunt for an as-yet unnamed armed group that they say is responsible for the shooting. (kmt)

-------------------------------

https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2020/05/24/papuan-armed-group-accused-of-shooting-covid-19-team-members.html
2) Papuan armed group accused of shooting COVID-19 team members

News Desk 
The Jakarta Post  Jakarta   /   Sun, May 24, 2020   /   03:40 pm

Military and police personnel belonging to the Nemangkawi task force in Intan Jaya regency, Papua, are on a manhunt for an armed group that purportedly shot members of a local COVID-19 response team.
As reported by Antara News Agency, the Nemangkawi joint task force released a statement on Saturday saying an armed group had shot two health workers affiliated with the local COVID-19 task force in Wandai district, Intan Jaya regency, on Friday at 4:30 p.m. local time.
The two medical workers – identified as Amalek Bagau, 30, and Eniko Somou, 39 – were shot while delivering medical supplies to a remote area in Intan Jaya regency.

The Nemangkawi task force, with the assistance of the Intan Jaya Police, managed to locate and evacuate the victims and transferred them to the Nabire General Hospital on Saturday morning, according to the statement.
Papua Police spokesperson Sr. Comr. AM Kamal said Amalek had survived the incident, but was in critical condition, while Eniko had died from his wounds.
“It took us about five hours to arrive at the crime scene,” Kamal said, citing difficulties in navigating the steep terrain.
The case is the latest in a recent string of violence that has resulted in the deaths of civilians in the region.
In April, two young Papuans, Eden Armando Bebari and Ronny Wandik, were allegedly shot to death by security forces in Mimika regency after being mistaken for members of an armed separatist group. 
A week before that, New Zealander Graeme Thomas Wall, an employee of gold and copper mining company PT Freeport Indonesia, was killed by gunmen in the area. (rfa)
-------------------------

Saturday, May 23, 2020

Vanuatu West Papua Association briefs new Government on West Papua


https://dailypost.vu/news/vanuatu-west-papua-association-briefs-new-government-on-west-papua/article_baba306e-9baf-11ea-9fc8-7b76fcb3c609.html

Vanuatu West Papua Association briefs new Government on West Papua

By Len Garae May 22, 2020






Two new members join VWPAUC with Chairman Pastor Alan Nafuki seated front right


Chairman of Vanuatu West Papua Association and Unification Committee (VWPAUC), Pastor Alan Nafuki has confirmed that all relevant West Papua related documents to brief the Government how far his Committee has progressed regarding its drive to help the United Liberation Movement of West Papua, have been handed over to the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Mark Ati and Prime Minister Bob Loughman.
In his other hat as Chairman of the Vanuatu Christian Council he also reminds the nation of the commissioning of the Government Leaders by the VCC, while presenting them with Bislama Bibles from the Bible Society. “It is our hope that all 52 Members of Parliament will read their Bible because we believe that as long as you are with God, your leadership will be in line with God’s leading to success”, Pastor Nafuki said.
“I also stressed the importance of unity, restoration and success in line with the success story of the Israelites in the Old Testament on their 40 years of wandering to reach the Promised Land in Canaan.
“Like the Israelites, today after 40 years, we want to regain our unity to restore all our land resources which we failed to achieve as late as last year, and this year we want to regain our resources to achieve success through the leadership of both Government and Opposition.

“I want to let the world know that Vanuatu is the only country in the world that stands united in support for the freedom of the people of West Papua.
“Vanuatu stands alone with only 250,000 people that unanimously support the freedom of the people of West Papua, no other country in the world has progressed that far on the issue regarding West Papua or any country for that matter.
“It is our prayer that the people of West Papua will also gain their freedom to enjoy the privileges that people of the free world like us are enjoying”.
He says it is his committee’s prayer that the new Government will adopt the same 100% spirit of support of the former Government, Opposition, Churches, Chiefs, Women, Youths, Non-Government Organisations, and Civil Society.

---------------

1) Armed criminal group shoots medical workers in Papua


2) 26 medical workers in Papua exposed to COVID-19  
3) Uprising in West Papua

-------------------------------------------

1) Armed criminal group shoots medical workers in Papua

 7 hours ago




Indonesian military and police personnel hunt for members of an armed criminal group believed to have shot civilians in Tembagapura, Papua. (ANTARA/HO/Humas Polda Papua)

Jayapura (ANTARA) - An armed criminal group reportedly shot two medical workers, one of them fatally, while they were delivering medicines for COVID-19 patients in Intan Jaya District of Papua Province.

 

The two medical workers have been identified as Almalek Bagau and Eunico Somou, chief of the Intan Jaya District Police, Adjunct Senior Commissioner Yuli Karre Pongbala, said on Friday.

 

Eunico Somou reportedly died of gunshot wounds, while Almalek, who is in critical condition, has been rushed to Pastoral Wandai for treatment.

 

"We plan to go to the scene (of the shooting) on Saturday (May 23, 2020) to evacuate the victim," Yuli said, adding it will take five hours to reach the spot. (INE)


Related news: 26 medical workers in Papua exposed to COVID-19


Related news: COVID-19: 38 medical workers in Bengkulu Province quarantined

 

EDITED BY INE

 
Reporter: Evarukdijati/Suharto
Editor: Fardah Assegaf

————————————

2) 26 medical workers in Papua exposed to COVID-19  
7 hours ago

Jayapura, Papua (ANTARA) - A total of 26 medical workers in the easternmost Indonesian province of Papua have been exposed to the novel coronavirus disease 2019, or COVID-19, and some of them are receiving medical treatment, a spokesperson said.

 

The medical workers include doctors and health laboratory officers, spokesperson for the Papua Province Task Force for the Handling of COVID-19, Dr. Silwanus Sumule, said on Friday night.

 

Some of the medical workers were employed in the provincial capital of Jayapura and the district of Jayawijaya, he said.

 

While some medical workers have recovered from the infection, others are receiving medical treatment, he informed.

 

As of Friday, 152 of the total 568 people who tested positive for COVID-19 in Papua have recovered from the disease, he added.

 

Confirmed coronavirus cases have been reported from 12 out of 29 districts and municipalities across Papua, the spokesperson revealed.

 

He said a total of 2,862 people have been placed under monitoring (ODPs) and 808 patients are under surveillance (PDPs) for COVID-19 in Papua.

 

Given the higher number of ODPs and PDPs, he expressed the hope that local residents would take the initiative and go to hospitals and health clinics to check whether they have been exposed to COVID-19. (INE)
 

Related news: Surabaya administration condoles death of doctor from COVID-19
 

Related news: Sixteen health workers contracted COVID-19 in Probolinggo
 

EDITED BY INE
Reporter: Evarukdijati/Suharto
Editor: Fardah Assegaf
——————————————



ABC Saturday extra

3) Uprising in West Papua

By Geraldine Doogue on Saturday Extra
The war is not ending, it is beginning is the sub title to investigative journalist John Martinkus latest book on the continued struggle in West Papua for a referendum on independence from Indonesia. It is a confronting statement knowing the violence that has plagued that region since the 1960s.
Guest: John Martinkus, investigative journalist who has covered Asia and the Middle East. Previous books include A Dirty Little WarTravels in American IraqIndonesia's Secret War in AcehLost Copy: the Endless Wars, Iraq and Afghanistan and the Quarterly Essay Paradise Betrayed: West Papua's Struggle for Independence
Book: The Road: Uprising in West Papua
Publisher: Black Inc Books
--------
----------------

Friday, May 22, 2020

1) GUEST BLOG: Maire Leadbeater – Political prisoners and Covid May 19


2) Task force spokesman reports 134 COVID-19 recoveries in Papua  
3) Civilian shot dead by armed group in Indonesia's Papua
4)Papuan farmer dies after alleged police assault at palm oil company
-----------------------------------


https://thedailyblog.co.nz/2020/05/22/guest-blog-maire-leadbeater-political-prisoners-and-covid-may-19/

1) GUEST BLOG: Maire Leadbeater – Political prisoners and Covid May 19



For millions around the world COVID 19 is one more terrible threat to an existence already  precarious because of poverty and conflict.  Others are at high risk because they are in detention at the behest of repressive governments.   UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres  has called for global solidarity in the fight against the virus and for an immediate global ceasefire.   His colleague Michelle Bachelet the Human Rights Commissioner has urged all governments to release political prisoners and those detained for critical dissenting views.
UN member states, such as New Zealand need to do their bit to support the global body. New Zealand has a big advantage here if only it would use it. 
We have earned a lot of respect in the last couple of years.  First because of the way our Prime Minister Ardern   faced up to the Christchurch Mosque killings, supporting and caring for the victims and ensuring prompt changes to our gun laws.  Right now our handling of the COVID 19 crisis is seen to have been up among the best.   It has been a ‘lives first – economy second’ approach and it has worked.  Jacinda Ardern’s leadership was seen to be firm but evidence-based and transparent. 
So what could we do with this earned capital?   For one thing we could look close to home and speak out for the people of Indonesian-controlled West Papua, most urgently for its political prisoners. Indonesia released over 30,000 prisoners in the wake of the COVID crisis;  prisoners who were close to serving their time or detained for less serious crimes.  However when it came to political prisoners, including  those detained for taking part in anti-racism demonstrations,  it was nothing doing.
To put this in context,  when  Covid struck West Papua the people were dealing with the  aftermath of  a major  uprising that began last August. The protests were triggered by a prolonged racist attack on  Papuan students studying  in  Surabaya, East Java.   The students were imprisoned in their dormitory overnight while racist mobs chanted ‘get rid of the Papuans’ and ‘monkeys, get out’.  Then armed security police threw in tear gas and arrested the students.

Then  it was as if the damn had burst as Papuans took to the streets in protest,  not only across West Papua,  but also in Jakarta and  several other Indonesian cities.  Indonesian rule of West Papua has been bitterly contested ever since the territory was taken over in 1963, so it is not surprising that that the calls for independence were amplified.  The banned national flag the ‘Morning Star’ was everywhere. 
Indonesia does not tolerate any kind of dissent that challenges its right to rule, so the protests led to an inundation into the territory of thousands of additional troops.    Some protests turned violent, and some  59 people, both Papuan and migrant, lost their lives.  An internet block was imposed and maintained in some areas for three weeks or more.  Outside journalists were already banned, but ingenious West Papuans managed to get some video footage out to the world.  We could see images from the humiliating arrests where Papuan were forced to lie face down on open ground .
Veronica Koman is an Indonesian human rights lawyer, currently forced to live in exile because of her committed advocacy for the West Papuan rights. Veronica teamed up with a fellow international human rights lawyer, Jennifer Robinson, and human rights group TAPOL to take a case to the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention to seek their support for the release of 63 political prisoners who posed no threat to society whatsoever because  all have  been involved in peaceful protest actions.   All of them are in grave danger of contracting COVID 19 in Indonesia’s  crowded and unsanitary prisons.  The great majority (57) were arrested during the 2019 uprising and the charges against them related to their support for self-determination or to displaying the banned flag. These peaceful activities are protected under international law.
For example in Manokwari  a young woman activist, Sayang Mandabayang,  is on trial on  treason charges.   She was apprehended at the local airport last September  and discovered to have some 1,500 miniature West Papuan flags in her bag ‘made of paper and stick’.  She is also said to have made a speech at an anti-racism rally. A photo of this young woman nursing her baby behind bars   went viral.    
The’ Jakarta Six’ were convicted on treason charges on 24 April and were sentenced to between eight and nine months in prison. Their ‘crime’?  They took part in a rally on August 28, 2019, outside the State Palace in Jakarta, during which they unfurled the  West Papuan Morning Star flag. One of them is Surya Anta Ginteng,  spokesperson for the Indonesian People’s Front for West Papua,  the first non-Papuan Indonesian to be charged with treason in relation to the West Papuan self-determination movement. One has already been released, but there is great concern for the others  especially for   Ariana Elopere, the one woman in the group.  She is detained at Pondok Bambu Detention Center where 24 prisoners have tested positive for Covid 19.
Foreign Minister Winston Peters seems set against any humanitarian advocacy.   The master of the sidestep, he  writes to West Papua Action Auckland  that ‘all States should consider the guidance’ of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights.    However,  in the time of Covid,  we should remember that the United Nations relies on the strength of all its member nations and  the saying   ‘we are all in this together’  means we should be speaking out for the powerless and vulnerable.
 Maire Leadbeater is a human rights advocate and expert on West Papua.

---------------------------

https://en.antaranews.com/news/149130/task-force-spokesman-reports-134-covid-19-recoveries-in-papua

2) Task force spokesman reports 134 COVID-19 recoveries in Papua  
12 hours ago

Jayapura, Papua (ANTARA) - Some 134 out of the total 538 people testing positive for COVID-19 in the easternmost Indonesian province of Papua have recovered from the disease as of Thursday, according to a spokesman.

"We are upbeat about an increase in the number of patients recovering from the disease," spokesman for the Papua Province Task Force for the Handling of COVID-19 Dr Silwanus Sumule noted in a statement through live streaming on Thursday night.

Of the total recoveries, 49 were from Mimika District, 34 from the Jayapura Municipality, 23 from Jayapura District, 11 from Merauke District, four each from the districts of Keerom and Jayawijaya, three from Sarmi, two each from the districts of Biak and Central Mamberamo, and one each from the districts of Nabire and Digul.

Sumule revealed that 394 COVID-19 patients are receiving medical treatment at several referral hospitals.

"Papua has 16 referral hospitals for COVID-19,” he stated.
Related news: Ministry affirms 808 Indonesian Jamaah Tabligh members stranded abroad

Related news: Indonesia must produce domestic viral genome-based COVID-19 vaccine


EDITED BY INE

Reporter: Evarukdijati/Suharto
Editor: Fardah Assegaf

----------------------------

3) Civilian shot dead by armed group in Indonesia's Papua

Source: Xinhua| 2020-05-22 19:09:34|Editor: huaxia

JAKARTA, May 22 (Xinhua) -- A 35-year old civilian identified as Sakeus was shot by an armed group and found dead on Thursday in Timika, Indonesia's easternmost province of Papua, the provincial police's spokesman Ahmad Kamal 
said on Friday. The victim with wounds on his belly and neck was found around a mining area of mining company 
PT Freeport Indonesia in Papua's sub district of Tembagapura, Kamal was quoted by Indonesia's Antara news agency
 as saying. The incident was reported by a joint police-military force's personnel who heard the burst of gunfire, 
he said, adding that following the report police personnel went to the location of the incident and rushed the victim to Tembagapura hospital. The victim does not belong to PT Freeport Indonesia or a mining company consortium, 
said Kamal. Enditem

—————————————————————


4) Papuan farmer dies after alleged police assault at palm oil company

by Hans Nicholas Jong on 22 May 2020

  • An indigenous Papuan farmer, Marius Betera, has died after allegedly being assaulted by a police officer when complaining about a palm oil company bulldozing his banana plot.
  • Police at the district level have arrested the officer, but police at the provincial level deny he did anything wrong, claiming that Marius died of a heart attack and that an autopsy showed no signs of bruising.
  • Activists have demanded an independent investigation into the case, noting that the alleged assailant, Melkianus Yowei, was last year transferred from his post after assaulting an elderly indigenous woman.
  • The palm oil company, PT Tunas Sawa Erma (TSE), is a subsidiary of the Korindo Group, which has a track record of violating traditional and human rights in the Indonesian provinces of Papua and North Maluku.
JAKARTA — Activists in the Indonesian province of Papua are demanding an investigation into the death of an indigenous man who was reportedly assaulted by a police officer after complaining about his farm being cleared by a major palm oil company.
Marius Betera died on the way to a clinic in Boven Digoel district to seek medical aid on May 16, hours after the alleged assault at a field office of PT Tunas Sawa Erma (TSE), a subsidiary of palm oil and logging giant Korindo Group. He was buried on May 18.
“The perpetrator being a police [officer] who helped PT TSE has violated his duties and functions as a police,” a group of NGOs said in a statement.
“The act of violence … leading to the death of the victim is a criminal offense that must be held accountable before the court,” they added.
The incident stemmed from the morning of May 16, when Marius, a former security guard at PT TSE’s plantation, arrived at his banana plot on the company’s land and found it had been bulldozed. The company allocates land for its workers to plant their own crops that they can sell for extra income, and while Marius had resigned from PT TSE in August 2019, the company had allowed him to continue staying on site.
Marius went to the company’s field office to complain about his farm being cleared, saying the company should have notified him that it planned to do so. Because he’d gone there straight from his plot, he was carrying farming and hunting implements, including a machete and bow and arrows.
As he was leaving the company office, he was accosted by Melkianus Yowei, a police officer who was previously assigned to provide security at the plantation and continued to frequent the site because his wife works there. Eyewitness accounts describe the two men tussling over the implements. Melkianus managed to gain control of them and struck Marius repeatedly in the face with the bow. He then punched him several times in the head and neck, and kicked him in the stomach. According to some witnesses, Marius was left bleeding from the ear.
Marius then left for a nearby police post to file a complaint, but was told that the officer on duty was on a break. From there, he headed to the PT TSE clinic for treatment, but collapsed just outside the clinic, and was pronounced dead soon after.
NGOs have demanded that both the Boven Digoel district police and the Papua provincial police “undertake immediate action to catch the perpetrator and enforce the legal process through a trial of police ethics and a general court process, as well as passing a justifiable sentence.”
The groups and local media both noted that Melkianus had a history of violence against civilians, having been transferred away from the plantation in 2019 after assaulting an elderly indigenous woman.
The police have issued conflicting statements on the case. The Boven Digoel police chief, Syamsurijal, said his office had detained Melkianus and encouraged Marius’s family to press charges. The Papua police, however, denied any wrongdoing by Melkianus and said Marius died of natural causes.
“From the autopsy result, there was no bruising on the victim’s body,” Ahmad Mustofa Kamal, a spokesman for the provincial police, said as quoted by Kompas. “He died of a heart attack.”
Ahmad said Marius had arrived alive at the clinic but refused to get medical treatment.
“That’s deception,” said Okto Betera, Marius’s younger brother. “This is murder.”
Papuan indigenous rights organization SKP KAMe, which advocates for some of the communities affected by Korindo’s operations and is among the NGOs calling for justice in Marius’s death, said police were too quick to downplay the incident. Anselmus Amo, a pastor and director of SKP KAMe, said it was unethical for the police to clear Melkianus without an independent investigation.
“The police have the rights to respond, but don’t be so quick in determining the cause of death, going so far as declaring that it’s a hoax,” Amo told Mongabay.
“There should be an independent body that investigates [the case]. If not, then we will just trade opinions and arguments with each other.”
SKP KAMe and the other NGOs said PT TSE and other companies operating in the region should stop using the military and police in their disputes with locals.
“We view the company … has used a repressive approach to resolve problems that occurred and were carried out by means of violence, rather than deliberating to find the best solution for victims who felt aggrieved,” they said.
The company’s director, Vinoba Chandra, denied that PT TSE had called in the police when Marius arrived to complain. He also said the company had notified Marius to vacate the land in February, and that Marius didn’t hold any customary rights to the land, having come from outside the region.
Korindo Group said it would launch its own investigation into the incident and work with the local community and authorities. It said it would also immediately open a grievance channel for the case on its website and disclose the progress and results of the investigation.
U.S.-based campaign group Mighty Earth said Korindo’s response to the incident shouldn’t stop there, adding the company has a long track record of disregard for and exploitation of Papuan rainforests and indigenous peoples.
A two-year investigation of Korindo’s deforestation practices by the Forest Stewardship Council, prompted by a complaint filed by Mighty Earth, found that, among other violations, Korindo had violated traditional and human rights in Papua and North Maluku, Indonesia.
“Yet Korindo has largely dismissed these concerns, or, when it could no longer avoid accountability, merely paid lip service to agreements to improve its practices,” Mighty Earth senior campaign director Deborah Lapidus said. “One such agreement, as stated on the Korindo website, is to ‘resolve grievances promptly, responsibly, responsively, and proactively;’ yet [Marius] Betera’s grievance resulted in his death.”
Lapidus called on the FSC, which certifies its member companies’ adherence to environmental and human rights standards, to immediately open its own investigation into the case, especially in light of Korindo’s earlier agreement with the FSC to “comply with the principle of Free, Prior and Informed Consent (FPIC) and remediate its negative impacts on communities.”
Korindo has disputed the findings in the report.
Banner image: One of Korindo’s oil palm estates in Papua. Photo courtesy of Mighty Earth.
 FEEDBACK: Use this form to send a message to the author of this post. If you want to post a public comment, you can do that at the bottom of the page.
-----------------------------