Tuesday, October 26, 2021

1) News: Basque Parliament passes resolution in support of West Papua


2) Customary land rights recognised in West Papua district

3) MORE INVESTORS THAN INDIGENOUS PEOPLE MANAGING NATURAL RESOURCES IN PAPUA
4) AUSTRALIA-INDONESIA HELD BILATERAL MILITARY TRAINING, SENIOR OFFICER VISIT

---------------------------------------------


1) News: Basque Parliament passes resolution in support of West Papua

October 25, 2021 in News

On October 8, 2021, the Basque Parliament passed a motion of support with the West Papuan struggle. The resolution notes that, ‘over 500,000 people have died in a genocide against the indigenous population,’ denounces human rights violations against West Papuans, and calls for a UN visit to the territory.

The motion was proposed by member of the Basque Parliament, Oihana Etxebarrieta, and Senator Gorka Elejabarrieta. The resolution was passed with unanimous support from EH Bildu and the Spanish Socialist Party, the major party in Spain’s ruling coalition.

The resolution follows a motion passed by the Spanish Senate earlier in the year calling for an urgent visit by the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights.

Benny Wenda, Interim President of the ULMWP Provisional Government, said: ‘This is an example of true solidarity with those who are made voiceless by geopolitical interests. The people of West Papua have been suffering for so long under Indonesian colonial rule, but this motion gives my people a lot of confidence. The people of the Basque understand democracy and human rights, and we appreciate their support and solidarity.’

The full text of the agreement reads as follows:

Over 500,000 people have died in a genocide against the indigenous population. Thousands have suffered rape, torture, prison or have been “disappeared” after being detained. Basic human rights, such as freedom of expression, are denied, and West Papuans live in a constant state of fear and intimidation. The IPWP was created, with the involvement of exiled West Papua independence leader Benny Wenda, to defend the rights of West Papua. A network of parliamentarians from around the world who support self-determination for the people of West Papua through a free and fair referendum, and to denounce the illegality of the 1969 Act. EH Bildu is part of the network through our Senator Gorka Elejabarrieta, and based on our commitment to this cause, we brought this motion to the Committee and we have reached this unanimous agreement in which, amongst other points we:
 
– underline the demand for the State of Indonesia to allow the UN OHCHR
to visit west Papua and produce an independent report
 
– encourage the involved parties to seek a space for talks and dialogue,
which we believe is the best way to overcome conflict
 
– also denounce the serious violations of human rights taking place in
West Papua, leading the population into a situation of fear and
isolation that must end


———————————————
2) Customary land rights recognised in West Papua district
 5:53 pm on 26 October 2021

An environmental NGO has hailed a West Papua district head's decision to recognise customary land rights.
The head of Sorong Regency, Johnny Kamuru, has issued a decree on recognising rights of the Indigenous Peoples of Gelek Malak Kalawilis Pasa over land and forest in Sayosa sub district.
The 3,47-hectare land was being targetted by oil palm producers, who Greenpeace Indonesia's Kiki Taufik, said have been empowered by recent law changes that undermine customary rights.
Greenpeace said the Indonesian government is generally unwilling to enforce laws to stop deforestation on public lands or follow through on its climate commitments.
"The recent enactment of Indonesia's Omnibus Bill will jeopardise and put the republic's environment and social protections at risk," according to Greenpeace Indonesia.
It said standards of laws and regulations for the protection will be weakened and will bring Indonesian environmental and social safeguards even further than the generally accepted global standards in financing sustainable development.
In a new report, Greenpeace said Indonesia's national forest estate is riddled with illegal palm oil plantations, according to an analysis by Greenpeace Indonesia and Treemap.
Despite the designated area being off-limits to plantations, the analysis has found at least 600 plantation companies have illegal operations set up inside the forest estate, which includes National Parks, Ramsar Convention wetlands and UNESCO World Heritage sites.
These land areas represent some of the highest levels of biodiversity and are critical in tackling the climate crisis.

-------------------------------------------------

3) MORE INVESTORS THAN INDIGENOUS PEOPLE MANAGING NATURAL RESOURCES IN PAPUA
News Desk October 25, 2021 8:21 pm

Jayapura, Jubi – Lawmaker of Papua Legislative Council John NR Gobai said that forest products and other natural resources in Papua were mostly controlled by investors, who have permits from the central government, instead of Indigenous People. To date, Indigenous Papuans are still marginalized in natural resource management.

“Indigenous People work on natural resources with simple tools and their activities were considered illegal,” Gobai said during a webinar on Friday, Oct. 22, 2021.

According to Gobai, investors often prioritize profits over establishing equal relationships with Indigenous People and other stakeholders. Investors, Gobai said, also grabbed land belonging to Indigenous People, pitting Indigenous People against each other, which resulted in polarization in society.

“Investors also use security forces in land grabbing practices, which sometimes results in violence and human rights violations,” he said.

Gobai said that natural resource management models that ignore the existence of Indigenous People often make them lose their customary forests, which are their source of livelihood. This is presumably due to the weak supervision by the government, says Gobay.


“Even in law enforcement, injustice occurs. People who are said to be managing natural resources illegally are criminalized. While on the other hand, companies that violate the rules are often exempted from punishment,” he said.

The representative of the Indigenous People of Wembi Village in Manam District, Keerom Regency, Kosmas Boryam, said in the discussion that most of the customary forest in Wembi had been turned to oil palm plantations. However, the Indigenous People do not get any economic benefits from the plantations.

“Most of our forest has been converted into oil palm plantations. But do we enjoy the profit? Absolutely not,” Boryam said.

Boryam believed that forest sustainability was very important for Indigenous People in Papua, including in Keerom Regency. “We Indigenous People hunt in the forest because our income is not enough to pay for our children’s tuition. If we get prey, such as deer, we can sell it for school fees,” he said.

However, as the customary forests are getting depleted, Boryam said he did not know how the next generation of Keerom Indigenous People would thrive in life. Currently, the Indigenous People of Wembi are trying to grow cassava, vegetables, vanilla, and cocoa on the remaining land to support their livelihood. “We only live from farming. We hope that the government will pay attention to us, the Indigenous People in the village,” he said. (*)

Reporter: Arjuna Pademme

Editor: Aryo Wisanggeni G


—————————————————

4) AUSTRALIA-INDONESIA HELD BILATERAL MILITARY TRAINING, SENIOR OFFICER VISIT
News Desk October 25, 2021 8:27 pm

Jayapura, Jubi – September and October have been busy months for the Indonesian and Australian Army. Three joint exercises have been held in both countries. A senior officer in the Australian Army, Maj. Gen. Justin Frederick Ellwood, commonly known as Jake Ellwood, also paid a visit to Indonesia.

“We have resumed bilateral military training which marks an important milestone in our defense and security partnership,” said Australian Ambassador to Indonesia Penny Williams in a written statement received by Jubi on Thursday, Oct. 21, 2021.10.25

According to Williams, Indonesia was an important strategic partner. “The recent visits and joint training prove the importance of the relationship between Indonesia and Australia while we are seeking a way out of the COVID-19 pandemic,” she said.

Williams revealed that on Sept. 9, Ministers of Defense and Ministers of Foreign Affairs of the two countries met up to discuss bilateral strategic and security interests. The meeting was soon followed by a visit by Maj. Gen. Jake Ellwood, the commander of the Australian Army’s Division 1, to Jakarta.

In his visit, Ellwood met with senior officers of the Indonesian Army, as well as discussed with the Indonesian Army Chief of Staff, Gen. Andika Perkasa, the opportunities and initiatives to increase the level and complexity of joint training.

“It is a pleasure to be back in Indonesia as we begin to strengthen our Army’s bilateral relationship with Indonesia,” Ellwood said, as quoted in the press release.

On Sept. 24, Ellwood trained 165 members of the Indonesian and Australian Army in a two-week Junior Officer Combat Instructor Training (JOCIT) in Bandung, West Java.

“As our cooperation increases, the complexity of the operations we have to perform also increases. Activities like JOCIT are very important for both Australian and Indonesian Army,” said Ellwood.

Meanwhile, on Sept. 27, Indonesia’s Special Forces Units (Kopassus) and Australia’s Special Air Service Regiment (SASR) joined a counterterrorism training called the Dawn Komodo, in Sewang, West Java. The training is designed for participants to exchange counterterrorism skills, knowledge, and experience. Dawn Komodo remains one of the longest joint exercises conducted by special forces of the two countries.

In October, Australia also hosted training in Darwin, dubbed the Wirra Jaya exercise, for 200 Indonesian Army personnel. This year’s exercise, sponsored by the Australian Army, is the largest iteration of the exercise since it was initiated. Wirra Jaya is an annual three-week joint exercise between Australia and Indonesia to improve the infantry skills of soldiers of both countries and strengthen shared values and commitments to maintain a free and open Indo-Pacific region. (*)

Reporter: Dominggus Mampioper

------------------------

Sunday, October 24, 2021

1) Government's Performance Report 2021 neglects to mention conflict in Papua


2) TNI, health centre provide health service for Papua children 

-----------------------------------
1) Government's Performance Report 2021 neglects to mention conflict in Papua

CNN Indonesia – October 23, 2021


                                            Indonesian troops on patrol in Papua – Undated (Dok)

Jakarta – The government has released its 2021 Performance Report. The report however, does not contain an evaluation of the handling of conflicts which have occurred in Papua.

Yet, of late, there have been frequent armed conflicts between armed criminal groups (KKB) and the Indonesian military resulting in not a few lives being lost on both sides.

An Amnesty International report for example says that the human rights situation in Indonesia worsened in 2020. Amnesty also highlighted the problem of impunity which continues to haunt Papua and West Papua provinces.

According to Amnesty's records, there were at least 19 cases of alleged extrajudicial killings by security forces in Papua and West Papua resulting in the death of 30 people.

In September 2021 meanwhile, armed groups attacked and set fire to public facilities in Okhika, Star Highlands regency. A number of facilities such as the Okhika community healthcare centre (puskesmas), the house of the puskesmas head, healthcare workers' houses, a primary school building, a junior high school building, a teacher's house and the local village hall in Okhika district were burnt down.

Then in Kiwirok, an armed group allegedly set fire to a district office, the Kiwirok Papua Bank offices, the Kiwirok puskesmas, a doctor's house, a healthcare workers' barracks, an Inpres primary school, a teacher's home and a market.

During the incident several healthcare workers disappeared and were allegedly taken hostage by the separatist group. One of them, Gabriella Meilan was found dead.

In addition to this, as a consequence of the conflict in Papua, many people have been displaced. Such as the firefight between the TNI (Indonesian military) and police with an armed group in February in Intan Jaya which forced local residents to seek shelter at the St Misael Bilogal Catholic Church.

On the other hand, the government report titled "Powerful Indonesia, Growing Indonesia", which was released to coincide with two years of the President Joko "Jokowi" Widodo and Vice President Ma'ruf Amin's administration, includes a report on the government's commitment to development in Papua, ranging from human resources to bureaucratic improvements.

The report also boasts about the 20th National Games (PON XX) in the Land of the Cenderawasih as Papua is known. The government states that the holding of the National Games in Papua are a signs of a revival in Papua. (sfr)

[Translated by James Balowski. The original title of the article was "Laporan Kinerja, Pemerintah Tak Cantumkan Konflik Papua".]

Source: https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20211023051301-20-711246/laporan-kinerja-pemerintah-tak-cantumkan-konflik-papua



---------------------------


2) TNI, health centre provide health service for Papua children  
11 hours ago
Keerom, Papua (ANTARA) - Indonesian soldiers of the mechanised infantry battalion 403/Wirasada Pratista border security task force collaborated with health workers from Ubrub public health centre (puskesmas) to provide health service for residents in Somografi Village, Web Sub-district, Keerom District, Papua.

Task force commander Lieutenant Colonel Inf. Ade Pribadi Siregar stated the task force has a moral imperative to ensure that children living in the border areas are healthy and receive proper nurture, while carrying out its main duty to defend the national sovereignty.

Meanwhile, the task force's Somografi village post commander First Lieutenant Inf. RakaRegnata informed the health checks are performed to enhance children's health and optimise child development.

"We believe the health examination will make the children more healthy and not easily being infected with many diseases," Regnata said.

The health checks to Somografi village children were conducted by physical examination to examine the child's body weight and height and provision of medicines, vitamins, and extra food of healthy biscuits, he revealed.

"We hope the health checks will be beneficial for the public health and suppressing stunting and malnutrition cases in the village," Regnata remarked.

Village resident Lacerus Kwayot (49), who participated in the health examination programme, expressed his gratitude to the task force and the puskesmas team to provide the health checks for the village children.

"We express our utmost gratitude to the task force soldiers who assist us by providing health service and medicines for Somografi Village residents and children," Kwayot stated.

Related news: Papua: Police, TNI asked to stay alert ahead of year-end
Related news: Marked absence of puskesmas in 13 sub-districts in Papua's Jayawijaya

Reporter: Muhsidin, Nabil Ihsan
Editor: Sri Haryati

----------------

Saturday, October 23, 2021

1) Papua: Police, TNI asked to stay alert ahead of year-end


2) Papua COVID-19 recovery rate reaches 96.7%  

------------------------------


https://en.antaranews.com/news/195753/papua-police-tni-asked-to-stay-alert-ahead-of-year-end

1) Papua: Police, TNI asked to stay alert ahead of year-end  

8 hours ago



During a roll call at the Raider 20/IJK Infantry Brigade Headquarters in Timika, Mimika district, Papua province, on Friday (October 22, 2021), National Police chief General Listyo Sigit Prabowo thanked all police and TNI personnel for securing the convening of the 20th National Games. (ANTARA/Genta Tenri Mawangi)


Timika, Papua (ANTARA) - National Police chief General Listyo Sigit Prabowo has asked police and military (TNI) personnel in Papua to remain alert, citing the likelihood of an escalation in separatist terrorists' activities towards the end of the year.


"Ahead of this year-end, local issues potentially escalate," he noted while issuing directives to police and military personnel during a roll call in Timika, the capital of Mimika district, Papua province, on Friday.

 

"As a result, security disturbances may rise owing to the increased intensity of the armed Papuan groups' activities," he said.

 

The roll call was also attended by TNI Commander Air Chief Marshal Hadi Tjahjanto.


Related news: Report book on Widodo administration's achievements in Papua released

 

As part of precautionary measures, maintaining security awareness and alertness is indispensable, as was done during the convening of Papua's National Games (PON), Prabowo said.

 

"Please remain cautious until this year-end. Our recent success (in securing PON) made us proud. But, do not be caught off guard because there are tasks that we must carry out," he added.

 

During the roll call, held at the Raider 20/IJK Infantry Brigade Headquarters in Timika, he also thanked all police and TNI personnel involved in securing and safeguarding the convening of the 20th National Games.

 

Co-hosted by Jayapura city and the districts of Jayapura, Mimika, and Merauke in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, the multi-sport event was strategic for Indonesia and Papua, he said.


Related news: Kiwirok attack: Several surviving healthcare workers want to go home

 

The event convincingly demonstrated to Indonesians and the international community that Papua is safe and secure, and, therefore, is ready to host large-scale events, Prabowo remarked.

 

"These all can have happened due to the hard works of TNI, police, and various elements of society," he said.

 

Prabowo also touched upon how both police and TNI managed to stop criminal groups seeking to disrupt Papua's PON. As a result, the event ran in a safe and secure manner, he said.

 

Papua has lately attracted the media spotlight as the host of this year's PON National Games and National Para Games (Peparnas).


Related news: Amin expects indigenous people to benefit from Papua's development

 

The PON took place in Jayapura city and the districts of Jayapura, Mimika, and Merauke from October 2 to October 15 this year, while Peparnas will be held from November 2 to November 15.

 

At least 6,400 athletes and 3,500 officials from 34 provinces across Indonesia participated in Papua's PON National Games, which featured 37 events.

 

Meanwhile, 1,935 athletes and 740 officials will take part in the National Para Games in Jayapura city and Jayapura district. The games will feature 12 events.


Related news: Should the 1945 Constitution be amended or not?

Related news: ESDM Ministry initiates carbon trade to lower greenhouse gas emissions

Reporter: Genta TM, Rahmad Nasution
Editor: Fardah Assegaf






------------------------------------------

2) Papua COVID-19 recovery rate reaches 96.7%  
6 hours ago

Jayapura, Papua (ANTARA) - The recovery rate among COVID-19 patients in Papua has reached 96.7 percent, the regional COVID-19 prevention and handling task force has informed.

 

"It is true that the (COVID-19) recovery rate is high, which is 96.7 percent, or 41,352 people have been declared recovered from COVID-19," spokesperson for the task force, Dr. Silwanus Sumule, said here on Saturday.

 

Cumulatively, as of Friday, 42,763 people were confirmed positive for COVID-19 in the province while 41,352 people had recovered from the viral infection, he informed.

 

Currently, 0.5 percent or 195 people are still being treated in 16 districts and cities in Papua, he said.

 

Meanwhile, the number of residents who have died of COVID-19 is 1,216, or 2.8 percent, he noted.


Related news: Some 95.46 percent of Palangka Raya's COVID-19 patients get recovered

 

Of the 16 districts and cities where patients are still being treated for COVID-19, Keerom district has recorded the most patients at 42, he said.

 

The recovery rate among COVID-19 patients in Papua has been high as most people confirmed positive have been asymptomatic, he added.

 

Although the recovery rate is high, the community must continue to adhere to the health protocols and carry out COVID-19 vaccinations, he stressed.

 

"Do not be negligent in complying with the process considering that the COVID-19 virus is still around us," he cautioned.

Related news: Jakarta's Wisma Atlet emergency hospital records 132 daily recoveries

 

The first case of COVID-19 was confirmed in Indonesia in March 2020. According to data from the National Disaster Mitigation Agency (BNPB), as of October 23, 2021, at least 4,239,396 people have tested positive for COVID-19 in the country, while 4,081,417 people have recovered, and 143,176 people have succumbed to the deadly virus.


Related news: COVID vaccination coverage reaches 65.25% in Medan, N Sumatra

Related news: Indonesia's COVID-19 spokesperson urges public to get fully vaccinated


Reporter: Evarukdijati, Raka Adji
Editor: Fardah Assegaf

--------------------

Friday, October 22, 2021

1) LAWMAKER URGES MILITARY POLICE TO RELEASE INVESTIGATION RESULT ON SEM KOBOGAU’S DISAPPEARANCE


2)  Indonesia's Papua: A paradise to travel and develop
----------------------------


1) LAWMAKER URGES MILITARY POLICE TO RELEASE INVESTIGATION RESULT ON SEM KOBOGAU’S DISAPPEARANCE

News Desk October 22, 2021 1:22 pm

Jayapura, Jubi – Lawmaker of Papua Legislative Council John NR Gobai has demanded the XVII Cenderawasih Military Command’s Military Police to immediately release the results of their investigation on the disappearance of Sem Kobogau, a 51-year-old man and resident of Bunagopa Village, Ugimba District, Intan Jaya Regency.

Kobogau went missing on Oct. 5, 2021, after allegedly being taken by soldiers.

As the military police had deployed a team to probe the case, Gobai urged the military police to inform the public about the results. “The XVII Cenderawasih Military Command has sent the military police to Intan Jaya. Therefore, we’re asking the military police to be transparent regarding the investigation results. They must open the information to the public,” Gobai told Jubi on Thursday, Oct. 21.

According to Gobai, Kobogau’s family and the residents of Bunagopa Village continued to question the whereabouts of Sem Kobogau. Residents are worried if something grave happened to him.

“The people of Intan Jaya are still traumatized by the violence that has occurred [in the region] so far. The community saw two young men, Luther Zanambani and Apinus Zanambani, went missing last year, whose whereabouts are unknown to date,” Gobai said, adding that Kobogau’s family and neighbors were worried that Sem Kobogau would suffer the same fate as the Zanambani brothers, who had been missing since April 2020.


The residents of Bunagopa have tried to contact the Intan Jaya Police, asking about Kobogau’s whereabouts but to no avail.

Previously, XVII Cenderawasih Military Command’s head of Information Col. Reza Nur Patria said that if the investigation found the involvement of Indonesian Military (TNI) personnel, the soldier-perpetrator would be prosecuted according to law. (*)

Reporter: Arjuna Pademme

Editor: Edho Sinaga


—————————————————————

https://www.dailysabah.com/opinion/op-ed/indonesias-papua-a-paradise-to-travel-and-develop

2)  Indonesia's Papua: A paradise to travel and develop

BY MUHAMMET ALI GÜLER - RINI INDYASTUTI  OP-ED  OCT 22, 2021 12:05 AM GMT+3

This op-ed is the result of numerous discussions between me and my beloved Indonesian friend, Rini Indyastuti, who is a researcher on Indonesia's Papua and director of PT. Matahari Energi Rajawali, a limited liability company based in Indonesia and the Flying Hawk Institute. Before writing this article, Rini and I decided that instead of focusing on the conflicts, we should spotlight the region's beauties, difficulties and recommendations.

Initially, it is worth introducing Rini who has been a part of Papua's tourism and social activities for a long time. Rini guides professional climbers to the top of the Carstensz Pyramid and Mount Carstensz in Indonesia. She organizes social activities that allow tourists to interact with the inhabitants of Papua. She believes that it contributes to the developmental processes of the local culture and economy. According to Rini, the interaction between locals and tourists has countless benefits for both. For example, tourists’ visits to schools can broaden students' perspectives while giving a once-in-a-lifetime experience to visitors. The visits can also directly contribute to the local economy during village stays.

Indonesia consists of over 17,000 islands, which is why it is recognized as the largest archipelago in the world. In addition to this, there are several unique national symbols such as the Komodo dragon, the world’s largest lizard, which I used to see frequently in Malaysia and is the national animal of Indonesia. It also stands out as one of the top 10 countries with the highest biodiversity rates in the world. The country also has famous holiday destinations such as Bali. It will be an exciting adventure for those wishing to travel to Indonesia including Papua.

Papua of Indonesia

Rini said that “in the context of richness in natural resources and tourism potential in Papua, the lyrics of 'the land of Papua is a rich land, a small paradise fell to the earth' in a song is not an exaggeration.” Papua is an island province of Indonesia, which welcomes travelers with its rich marine biodiversity and its unique and natural beauty. Furthermore, sublime landscapes with the dense wilderness that still cover the expanse of the land of Papua make it even more attractive for nature lovers.

There are exotic plants and around 100 species of animals in Papua, which shares a border on the island with Papua New Guinea. This island province is blessed with natural resources such as minerals, gold, copper and at the same time with cultural and natural richness. For instance, there are almost 500 indigenous tribes with distinctive cultures and over 400 different languages.

Some of the wonderful destinations in Papua are Carstensz Pyramid as one of the Seven Summits in the world (the highest peaks of the seven continents), fantastic lakes in the towns of Enarotali and Sentani, the Lembah Baliem festival (which is an annual celebration of the diversity of the Baliem Valley), the amazing traditional wood carvings, stunning atolls in Raja Ampat Islands (an Indonesian archipelago off the northwest tip of Bird’s Head Peninsula in West Papua), and the beautiful beaches in the Kaimana and Padaido regions.

In a nutshell, nature and culture collide in a remarkable way and tourism in the region can contribute tremendously to the wellbeing of the community in Papua, all while travelers attain a sense of inner peace during their journeys in Papua.

The Joko Widodo era

In the past, Papua was a very isolated region due to its limited access to transportation which resulted in limited public access to proper health and education facilities.

Imagine this: people living in the mountainous areas of Papua had to walk for hours and even days through dense tropical rain forests and across dangerous rivers without bridges simply to receive health services when they got sick. Death due to infection is very common in rural communities but can be easily overcome if proper health facilities are available in the region.

In the era of President Joko Widodo, the little paradise began receiving investments. Some of the positive developments include the building of land transportation throughout Papua to improve accessibility to health and educational institutions, efforts to save time and make travel cost-effective to improve social and economic prosperity, construction of traditional markets in various areas to engage the community in business.

However, there are areas that still need to be focused on in order to improve the quality of living conditions in Papua. It is a necessity to increase the number of educational and health facilities and improve the quality of the existing ones across Papua. Such measures will be useful for all in all spheres of life. For instance, Papuan residents will be able to consolidate their knowledge about renewable sources and maximize the benefits for the community and the environment through their renewable energy instruments which may be taught in education centers. So, this small paradise will truly become the epicenter of a prosperous life and peaceful habitat for the indigenous Papuans as well as for migrants who have devoted their lives to Papua, and beyond.
---------------------

1) Residents of 4 Districts in the Bintang Mountains fled to PNG


2) West Papua activists call on Australia to stop joint exercises with the Indonesian military

3) ‘Politics of recognition’ needed for the betterment of Papua
4) Politically connected firm seeks to profit as Indonesian government cuts down orangutan habitat

---------------------------------

A google translate. 
Original Bahasa link

1) Residents of 4 Districts in the Bintang Mountains fled to PNG
Reporter: Benny Mawel  October 22, 2021 1:49 pm


Illustration of a number of buildings in Kiwirok District, Bintang Mountains which were allegedly burned by armed groups some time ago - IST

Papua No. 1 News Portal | Jubi Jayapura, Jubi – The authority of the Papuan Customary Council in the Bintang Mountains Regency said residents in four districts in the region had fled. They left their homes, villages, livestock and gardens, to areas that were considered safer, due to the deployment of security forces to the Kiwirok area, after gunfire and burning of public facilities in the area. It was stated. Antonius Uromabin, the daily chairman of the traditional council for the Ngalum Kupel region, told journalists Jubi at the office of the Papuan adat council, after bringing a report on the condition of the indigenous peoples in the Bintang Mountains. "Residents of the four districts evacuated," he said. The four districts in question are Kiwirok, Oklib, Okyob and Okika Districts. According to him, the residents of the four districts have fled since the gun battle between the TPNPB and the TNI to the burning of hospitals and other facilities in Kiwirok. Since then, residents of the four districts, empty.

“All of them (TNI/POLRI) took over the Kiwirok area. People all fled," he said. He said the customary council had not confirmed the number of people who had fled. His party only knew that the residents had fled to the district capital and to the Okbibab district. Because, the residents evacuated scattered when the incident erupted and dropped troops. “Their people are scattered, not all descend to Oksibil. I got a report of 1,500 people to Oksibil. To Oklip 800 people then went to Okbibab. Those who go to Okbiba do not enter the village but are in the border area because there is a garden,” he said. There are even residents of two districts, Okyop and Okika districts are empty. Its residents fled to the forest to the Tabubil area, Papua New Guinea.

“They are mostly next door (PNG). They haven't been back since the arson," he said. His side really hopes that the local government will ensure the conditions of the displaced people and can return them to their hometowns. "We hope that the government immediately goes to their respective districts, gathers people into the forests, then we slowly investigate who did it," he said. Pastor Dean of the Bintang Mountains, DR James Kossay said it was true that there were residents who fled to the city of Oksibil and into the forest. But he could not confirm the amount. Because, they have not received a definite report. "Well, I'll try to check first. Later, I will inform you,” said Jubi to journalist some time ago. (*) Editor: Syam Terrajana

—————————————————

Green Left

2) West Papua activists call on Australia to stop joint exercises with the Indonesian military
Susan Price October 22, 2021 

Issue  1322 West Papua

About 200 Indonesian military personnel are taking part in a joint training exercise with 150 Australian troops in the Northern Territory. Meanwhile, in West Papua, thousands of civilians are fleeing Indonesian military operations in the Maybrat region.

According to the Civil Society Coalition for Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs), more than 2768 indigenous Papuans from 50 villages in the Aifat Selatan, Aifat Timur, Aifat Timur Jauh, Aifat Timur Tengah and Aifat Timur Selatan districts have fled their homes.

They fear being arbitrarily arrested or tortured during the Maybrat operation, which has been ongoing since September 2. According to the coalition, the IDPs have sought shelter in the nearby districts of Aiyawasi, Kumurkek and Aitinyo, as well as other regencies, such as Sorong, South Sorong and Bintuni.

The coalition counted 40 elderly people, 4 pregnant women, 338 minors and 17 infants among IDPs originating from the Aifat Selatan District alone.

As at October 2, 51 of these IDPs are experiencing health issues. One IDP has reportedly died.

Human rights activists in Pegunungan Bintang Regency have uploaded a  showing a group of IDPs from the Kiwirok District, Pegunungan Bintang Regency.

The video shows about 60 people — mainly women, elderly people and children — sitting together in the jungle. One of the women is sharing raw leaves and several bananas among the children. Another raises her voice and appeals to the group in the indigenous Ngalum language: “Indonesia[n soldiers] came and burnt our villages to the ground. We have already fled to the forest for one month. There is hardly any food so all children must eat what we have.”

Australia West Papua Association spokesperson Joe Collins said: "We have not heard a single word of concern from Canberra about the plight of West Papuans fleeing military operations, or about the ongoing human rights abuses in the territory.

“Yet, Vanuatu's Prime Minister Bob Loughman did, when he addressed the 76th UN General Assembly."

Loughman  that the indigenous people of West Papua continue to suffer human rights violations under Indonesian rule.

Collins said: “Canberra is always ready to condemn human rights abuses in other parts of the world, particularly if it also has US backing, but refuses to criticise Jakarta about abuses committed by its military in West Papua, one of our nearest neighbours.

“Instead of increasing defence cooperation with the Indonesian military we should have a moratorium on all training with the Indonesian military and Canberra should be calling on Jakarta to halt all security force operations in the territory.”

While the situation in West Papua is “seriously deteriorating” , on a recent visit to Jakarta by Foreign Minister Marise Payne and Defence Minister Peter Dutton the two countries agreed “to strengthen security ties leading to joint military training in Australia and participation in its defence academies”.

“Australia has also donated 15  (PMV) to Indonesia,” said AWPA.

Collins said, “while the Indonesian security forces are committing human rights abuses and conducting military operations in West Papua, there should be a monitorium at the least on all military aid to the Indonesian defence forces.”

, how a newly-released, unredacted intelligence report reveals that an Australian intelligence officer provided the Australian government with compelling evidence, just 11 days after a massacre on the island of Biak, in July 1998, that Indonesia “almost certainly used excessive force against pro-independence demonstrators”.

The same officer was also handed photographic evidence by West Papuans on Biak, at great risk to their safety. The photos were distributed to his superiors within the department of defence, but never saw the light of day. No Indonesian military personnel have ever been charged with their involvement in the massacre.

A petition  has been launched on change.org.





———————————————


3) ‘Politics of recognition’ needed for the betterment of Papua

Vidhyandika D Perkasa (The Jakarta Post)
 PREMIUM Jakarta   ●   Fri, October 22, 2021

Papua is commonly linked with human rights violations, under-development, discrimination, racism and questions about the history of integration. However, from Oct. 2 to Oct. 15, Papua hosted the 20th National Games (PON), which received praise from both the domestic and international communities for its “elegant and luxurious” organization, supported by the establishment of world-class sport infrastructure and facilities. 

In such case, PON in Papua could be seen as “a new deal for Papua”, as the sporting event has served as a mediating structure that transforms Papua’s “marginalization and alienation” into “recognition”. Theoretically, the politics of recognition have played an important role in the fight of marginalized and minority groups in Papua who have seen themselves as both unequal and distinct from a dominant majority within the nation state. 

The recognition could further promote Papua as an “integral” part of Indonesia and instil a sense of pride given Papua’s capacity to hold a successful national sporting event. This recognition was complemented by the host province’s success in finishing fourth among 34 provinces in the medals tally. PON also provided opportunities to people – athletes, officials, spectators – from outside of Papua to experience Papua and its diverse cultures. 

The event also allowed outsiders to interact with indigenous Papuans, to understand local people’s characters and therefore debunk the bleak narrative and image about Papua. From the economic perspective, PON stimulated the local economy. Prior to the 20th PON, efforts to solve Papua’s complexity provided minimum breakthroughs despite massive infrastructure development initiated by President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo. Ironically, the huge infrastructure development and the revision of the Special Autonomy Law were not seen by the majority of Papuans as satisfactory solutions. 

Demands for fair resolution of past human rights violations, an end to violence, racism and discrimination, revisiting the history of integration, which all leads to the demand for a referendum, remain prominent agendas and could be seen as the manifestation of a struggle to achieve recognition. The essence of such grievances stem from the prolonged notion of Indonesia’s “mistreatment” of Papua. 

In connection with the situation, the Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) conducted research into what young Papuan people say about their identity. I was intrigued to ask my respondents what “Indonesia” meant to them. A Papuan student at one private university in Yogyakarta, for example, firmly stated that Papua is not Indonesian. Papua is only a territory “within” Indonesia with no emotional bond. She clearly highlighted the differences in race as one reason. Papuans are Melanesian and the rest of the Indonesian people are Malay. Other Papuan youth “imagined” Indonesia as a colonizer of Papua. 

Another source of grievance is the racism that most Papuans, especially those studying in universities outside of Papua, experience almost on a daily basis. A Papuan student admitted to being humiliated by her own lecturer in class when discussing gender. The common narrative of woman’s beauty according to the lecturer was white, slim, long nose, long hair and she was not in that category. She also found difficulties in finding a boarding house in Yogyakarta because she is Papuan. The public has stigmatized Papuans as criminals, alcoholics and troublemakers. 


According to one Papuan youth, racism is a social construct with strong economic and political motivations. It is a means to create a sense of inferiority and discourage self-confidence so the Papuans will not rebel against outside forces exploiting natural resources in the province. Because of racism, the Papuan youth felt afraid to interact with non-Papuans; afraid to take opportunities that were offered. Afraid of being teased, humiliated and downgraded, therefore, most Papuan students avoid interaction with non-Papuans. 

The government and the public are viewed as perpetuating “differences” both in terms of appearance and character (Papuans are uncivilized and backward). Political violence is reproduced in and through representations of culture and difference (Kirsch, 2002). 

A focus group discussion participant was furious when other Indonesians thought she originated from Africa. This shows that Papua is not well “introduced” to the rest of Indonesian society. One respondent also argued that their fellow Indonesians visualized Papua as “traditionalist” and backward. Papuan youths feel there is always an attempt to “force” Papuans to become Indonesians but there has never been any effort to make Indonesia understand Papua.  

Based on the above explanation, we can identify that there are various issues that seemingly segregate Papuans from Indonesian society, such as exploitation of the politics and culture of differences, stigmatization and discrimination. Even though we have to admit that allowing Papua to host PON by itself would not eliminate the embedded delicate problems in Papua, it could be treated as part of a nation-building project to promote positive progress in the easternmost territory. 

Nation building constitutes a process whereby a society or community of people with diverse origins, histories, languages, cultures and religions come together within the boundaries of a sovereign state. Papuan youths should play an important role in this project since they act upon their own initiative in deconstructing Papua’s history and future trajectories. During PON in Papua, President Jokowi initiated the Papuan Youth Creative Hub, which will be operationalized in 2022, as part of the politics of recognition to give youth more of a role to play. In general, the 20th PON in Papua succeeded in creating a melting pot for integration and interaction of diverse people, including between indigenous Papuans and the migrant population in Papua. 

Sporting events could be used to eradicate the divisions, stigmatization and injustices with the aim to fostering unity and promoting national consciousness about Indonesia and a commitment to developing the country. It is time for us to recognize and trust Papua’s capacity. For the indigenous Papuans it is a moment to achieve self-confidence, self-esteem and a belief in their ability to progress. 

All this falls within the framework of the politics of recognition. Although PON is over, we must maintain this positive momentum and plan world-class events in Papua. We need to strive for a better Papua and promote justice and equality under the nation-building project.   

 *** The writer is a senior researcher, Department of Politics and Social Change, Centre for Strategic and International Studies, Jakarta. 

—————————————

4) Politically connected firm seeks to profit as Indonesian government cuts down orangutan habitat

The Gecko Project| 14 October 2021

Published: 14 Oct 2021

  • The Indonesian government has stripped back rules protecting the environment to expedite a plan to ramp up food production through a “food estate” programme.
  • A firm run by allies of the Minister of Defence has positioned itself to profit from the programme and is seeking $2 billion in investment.
  • Analysts say numerous rules have been broken and there are huge conflicts of interest at play, as the government sets its sights on the forests of Papua.

This article is the result of a collaborative investigation with Tempo.

When the Indonesian government announced ambitious plans to ramp up domestic food production as the pandemic set in last June, officials claimed that it would not lead to “environmental destruction”.

Instead, as COVID-19 threw the world’s supply chains into disarray, officials would ward off the threat of an impending food crisis by boosting crop yields and promoting modern, environmentally sensitive farming techniques.

But within five months, workers acting under the instructions of the Ministry of Defence had fired up their chainsaws to cut down orangutan habitat in Borneo and replace it with a giant plantation.

The story behind this plantation reveals how the ministry has exploited regulations that were drafted hastily during the pandemic, stripping away environmental safeguards and opening up vast new areas of land for agriculture.

An investigation by The Gecko Project and Tempo discovered that the ministry moved so fast that it failed to comply even with these scaled-back rules, potentially illegally clearing hundreds of hectares of rainforest.

The plantation in Borneo, which could take over 32,000 hectares of land that for now is still mostly rainforest, represents just a fraction of the ministry’s ambitions. After Defence Minister Prabowo Subianto was handed a central role in the “food estate” programme, his officials drew up plans to plant more than one million hectares of cassava, a root vegetable, across the country.

The investigation also discovered evidence that the Ministry of Defence is attempting to steer food estate projects, which are potentially worth billions of dollars, to a company with no discernible track record in developing plantations. The company, PT Agro Industri Nasional, or Agrinas, is staffed by individuals from Prabowo’s inner circle.

Agrinas is owned by a non-profit foundation also controlled by Prabowo, with the support of a string of retired and serving top-ranking military officers. Analysts have questioned whether the ownership structure is legal, because it appears to violate rules that are meant to ensure such foundations serve charitable purposes.

They also say Prabowo’s close relationships with Agrinas’s executives and board members generate serious conflicts of interest.

Agrinas and the Ministry of Defence deny partnering on the food estate programme. Despite these denials, we found that Agrinas has sought $2 billion in investment from a foreign government by referencing its privileged access to the programme and connections to Prabowo.

Our investigation also found that the defence ministry is now moving ahead with its plan to develop further plantations in Papua, a biodiversity hotspot in the east of the country that holds part of the largest tract of intact rainforest in Asia.

The ministry’s efforts there are being led by a retired naval officer, who says the labour on plantations will be provided by young Papuans recruited into a newly-formed reserve military corps. Soldiers have already been deployed in support of the programme in Borneo.

The involvement of the military in Papua raises serious concerns, critics say, because the military has a track record of committing human rights abuses against the region’s indigenous population in the interests of advancing natural resource extraction and plantation projects.

The ministry has already presented plans to plant rice and cassava on thousands of hectares of forest and indigenous land in Merauke, a highly militarised district in the furthest eastern reaches of the country. But it has failed to share these plans with the people that they most affect. Local Papuan communities, whose legal rights have been eroded by the new regulations, remain in the dark.

President Joko Widodo, known as Jokowi, launched Indonesia’s food estate program on the back of warnings of an impending global food crisis as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic.

The spread of the virus could be “catastrophic” for millions of people across the world living on the cusp of hunger, the chief economist at the World Food Programme said in April 2020.

UN bodies asserted that the problem was not how much food was being produced. Rather, the danger was that food might not get to where it was needed, as supply chains were gummed up by border restrictions and workers were forced to stay at home, and it could become too expensive for families hit hard by the economic slowdown.

But reducing Indonesia’s reliance on food imports by producing more domestically is a perennial obsession of the nation’s political class, one that arose as a topic of debate in the last two presidential elections. Jokowi instructed his ministers to deliver on this ambition and address the impending pandemic-driven crisis by growing more staple foods such as rice.

 
 

The licensing process for agricultural plantations was lengthy. Companies were required to get approval from numerous government agencies, consult with local communities and carry out environmental impact assessments. Large areas of land and forest were off-limits to agriculture, to protect watersheds and maintain forest cover.

Officials in the capital, Jakarta, got to work designing regulations that would cut through the bureaucracy. As the new rules began to emerge, observers suspected the government was prioritising speed over legal principles and the environment.

For Adrianus Eryan, a legal researcher at the Indonesian Center for Environmental Law, or ICEL, the first sign was an environment ministry “operational plan” that he found online in mid-2020. The document outlined plans to turn vast swathes of land in four provinces into “food estates”.

Normally, Adrianus said, such guidance would come after regulations were released. There was no legal basis to enact the changes the ministry had laid out. “This was a bit strange, because it was backwards,” he added.

When the first food estate regulation was enacted in October 2020, it revealed the potential scale of the changes. The new regulation handed the government the ability to use potentially millions of hectares of land previously unavailable for food plantations, including areas designated as protected forests.

The regulation allowed the government to implement these changes with few checks and balances. It demanded a suite of documents, including management plans and environmental permits. But most of these can be produced after land is opened up. Rezoning areas for the food estate only requires a “commitment” to complete them.

The principal requirement is for officials to carry out a strategic environmental assessment, known by its Indonesian acronym as KLHS. The assessments are lengthy analyses that involve extensive public consultation and are used to inform long-term planning.

But the regulation also allows for a “rapid” KLHS, a format that was developed for use in emergency situations. This format relies on the judgement of experts over empirical evidence, according to an ICEL analysis. ICEL found that rapid KLHS “tend to be speculative and leave a lot of room for uncertainty”, and questioned the justification for their use in the food estate programme.

Walhi, a national green group, called the rapid assessment “baseless” and urged the ministry to repeal the entire regulation. This July, the regulation was updated, but there were few substantive changes.

Yeka Hendra Fatika, a member of the national Ombudsman, which monitors how the government delivers public services, said that even a year after the programme was announced it remained unclear who was running it and how it would be financed. The lack of formal planning created the “potential for maladministration”, he added.

Within two months of the first food estate regulation being issued, the fears of a global food crisis had waned, according to a World Bank analysis published in December 2020. Countries had started exporting crops again and the trade in most staple foods was expected to increase for the first time in four years.

The problems for poor Indonesian families, according to the World Bank, were high food prices, caused by a range of issues including processing and transport costs, and limited access to nutritious foods like fruit and vegetables. The food estate programme, which principally targeted production of rice and cassava, would not directly address either problem.

“The structural problems can’t be solved by large-scale land clearing,” said Bhima Yudhistira, an economist and director of the Center of Economic and Law Studies.

In its December 2020 analysis, the World Bank cautioned that the success of the food estate would depend, in part, on “the management of environmental and social risks”. By then, however, the government had begun to cut back the social and environmental safeguards that might slow it down.

In an interview this September, Moeldoko, Jokowi’s chief of staff, said the legislative process was justified by the urgency of the “food crisis”.

“We are racing against time,” he told us. “If the intention is to serve the people, the safety of the people is the highest law.”
plans to intensify rice production in a region of peat swamps in the south of Borneo. Critics noted quickly that it revived a notoriously disastrous plan in the same location, two decades earlier, that had led to the swamps being drained, generating vast greenhouse gas emissions but very little rice.

The Ministry of Environment and Forestry was keen to allay concerns that the new programme would also result in environmental damage. It would instead focus on the rehabilitation of protected areas that had been illegally deforested, as well as agroforestry, which weaves crops through forests without clearing them.

“Another key concern for us is to ensure that no Bornean orangutan habitat is targeted,” said Siti Nurbaya, the environment and forestry minister.

But president Jokowi had also handed responsibility for the programme to his Minister of Defence and former election rival, Prabowo Subianto. In the same month that Jokowi toured the peatlands in southern Borneo, military officers and defence ministry officials were meeting with the local government 150 kilometres north, in a district called Gunung Mas.

There, indigenous Dayak communities live along broad rivers that meander south from the mountains in the centre of the island, through rainforests and on to the Java Sea. The ministry set its sights on a stretch of wilderness east of the Kahayan River, where locals gather food, rubber and wood.

“It’s all wrong. The community is pushing us for answers”

In interviews with our reporters, village leaders recounted meetings with ministry officials and a senior military officer in July, just one month after the food estate was launched. The visitors from Jakarta had explained their intention to establish a plantation to help secure Indonesia’s food needs. But the details remained vague. The villagers weren’t told where the project would be, or when it would start.

Within a few weeks, Prabowo submitted a request to the environment ministry to establish a food estate nearly half the size of Jakarta, the capital city, in Gunung Mas. At the time, no regulation had yet described what a food estate area was, much less how it could be created.

Overlaying the borders of the proposed site with satellite imagery reveals that the majority was rainforest at the time the proposal was made. According to assessments endorsed by the Indonesian government, most of the area is orangutan habitat.

“At the beginning, they didn’t tell us that it would be as large as 30,000 hectares,” said Mine Yantri, a village head who joined the meetings in July. “We couldn’t really oppose a government programme.”

The clearing began in mid-November, when the food estate regulation was just three weeks old.

Though they had been involved in some early meetings, the communities living in nearby villages still had little information. Sigo, an indigenous leader from Tewai Baru village, was on a routine trip to gather wood when he found his path blocked by soldiers guarding the land. Villagers began accusing community leaders like Sigo of selling off their land behind their backs.

“It’s all wrong,” Sigo said. “The community is pushing us for answers.”

The defence ministry did not hold its first public consultation for a strategic environmental assessment — required to rezone the land — until February, three months later. By that point, more than 600 hectares had already been cleared.

presentation given to a parliamentary hearing in March 2021 indicated that the ministry had still not yet met the conditions needed to rezone the land. The land was categorised as ‘permanent production forest’. Under a long-standing principle of Indonesian forestry law, such areas cannot be converted to agricultural plantations.

Adrianus, from ICEL, said the sequence of events indicated that there was “likely a violation” of the law. “With this food estate there have been many safeguards ignored,” he added. “The KLHS was ignored, the community was not involved, the process was designed behind closed doors.”

The Ministry of Defence told us it had started land clearing by making use of a 2018 regulation that allows, in emergencies, the “borrowing” of land zoned for other uses without changing its status. It said they had then “made adjustments” when the 2020 food estate regulation was enacted. The clearing was “based on instructions from Jokowi during a cabinet meeting.”

“The process was designed behind closed doors”

When our reporter visited the site this August it was guarded by soldiers. Moeldoko, Jokowi’s chief of staff, told us the use of active duty soldiers was justified by the 2004 National Army law.

That law requires approval from the national parliament for their deployment, but we could find no record it had been given. Two security analysts told us the deployment was likely a violation of the law.

Despite the large amount of forest already cleared, by August this year only around 30 hectares of cassava had been planted. Our reporter found stalks that were wilted and yellow. Many appeared to have died.

Prabowo’s ambition is to plant more than a million hectares of cassava, using the root vegetable as a substitute for wheat as part of efforts to reduce Indonesia’s reliance on imports. The defence ministry also believes the crop can be used for a range of other products unrelated to food, from biofuels to pharmaceuticals.

But cassava plantations are not easy to establish, according to Reinhardt Howeler, a scientist who spent decades researching the crop. Smallholders produce most of the world’s supply, he said, and most plantations larger than a few hundred hectares are so labour-intensive that they are not economical. A 32,000 hectare cassava plantation would be the largest Howeler has heard of by a factor of at least five.

Professor Achmad Subagio, a cassava expert who was working on the ministry’s project in Gunung Mas but hadn’t visited the site since February, said that cassava requires intensive care for four months after planting. “If there is no maintenance fund, they will be skinny for sure,” he added.

In its haste, the ministry had cleared the rainforest before it had the budget to establish its plantation. Almost a year after it started cutting trees, it said it was “still waiting for the regulatory process and the budget” for the programme.

Read the full report by The Gecko Project here


----------------