Monday, March 1, 2021

AWPA Update No 1/ 2021

AWPA  Update No 1/ 2021

Welcome to our first update in 2021 and a belated happy new year to all.

 

Since our last update there have been regular clashes and shooting incidents between the Indonesian security forces and armed gangs.  The media in Indonesia usually blame the OPM for these attacks but it should be remembered that the mainstream media are quoting official security force spokespeople in reference to these attacks. There are many actors involved in West Papua but the truth will always come out through local media and the people in the territory. However in response to these attacks the security forces undertake military operations leading to human rights abuses, incidents of intimidation and torture of Papuan activists, human rights defenders and cause local people to flee creating internal refugees. The resources of West Papua continue to be exploited by Jakarta and the Papuan people face racism and discrimination on a daily basis. Two issues which have caused many protest/rallies by Papuans in the territory are the proposed division of the territory into more provinces and the rejection of the extension of the special autonomy package.

 

 


An audio report from Johnny Blades RNZ Pacific.

Counter claims over Papuan trio killed by Indonesian military

From Dateline Pacific, 23 February 2021 

The West Papua Liberation Army says three young men killed by Indonesia's military last week were civilians and died after being tortured. There's a different take on the deaths from Indonesia's military which claims the men were members of the pro-independence Liberation Army.

The deaths, in remote Intan Jaya regency, are the latest in a series of violent attacks in Papua province's rugged interior. Johnny Blades is here to give me the latest about the ongoing conflict.

https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/programmes/datelinepacific/audio/2018784676/counter-claims-over-papuan-trio-killed-by-indonesian-military




West Papua group denies army claims over killings

RNZ Pacific 22 Feb. 2021

The West Papua Liberation Army says three young men killed by Indonesia's military last week were civilians and died after being tortured and not shot while escaping. The deaths occurred at a health centre in Sugapa in Papua province. A spokesman for Indonesia's military says the three men were members of an armed group, a euphemism for the West Papua Liberation Army.

He says one of the three had gone to the health centre after fleeing from military officers who suspected he was behind an earlier fatal attack on an Indonesian soldier.


The coffins of three West Papuan men killed by Indonesia's military on 16 February 2021 in Sugapa, Intan Jaya regency. Photo: Supplied


The Papuan had sustained a gunshot wound, and was reportedly visited by two relatives in the clinic before the military came for them. The military says the men were shot trying to escape. But the Liberation Army claims the men were civillians and they died after being beaten and tortured. The Liberation Army has confirmed that it was responsible for the death of an Indonesian soldier in Intan Jaya the previous day, Monday 15 February. It was the latest death in ongoing violent exchanges between the Libration Army's guerilla fighters and Indonesian security forces across several regencies in Papua's remote interior.

 


In a statement to the high level segment of the 46th session of the UN Human Rights Council, the  Forum SG raised the issues of COVID-19, Climate Change and West Papua.


West Papua (Papua)

Excellencies, the violent conflict and subsequent human rights violations in West Papua (Papua) has been a concern for the Pacific Island Forum Leaders for over 20 years. In 2016, it become a standing agenda item for Forum Leaders.

Pacific Island Forum Leaders’ focus on West Papua has been squarely on human rights – calling on all parties to protect and uphold the human rights of all residents, and to work to address the root causes of the conflict by peaceful means.

In recent years, the escalation of tension and alleged human rights violations on both sides of the conflict, particularly against innocent civilians, has deepened the collective concerns of the Leaders of the Pacific.

When our Leaders met in Tuvalu two years ago, they welcomed the invitation by the Government of Indonesia for a mission to West Papua by the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, and strongly encouraged both sides to finalise the timing of the visit. Leaders also called for an evidence-based report on the situation in West Papua to be provided before their next meeting.

We call on distinguished Council Members to encourage all relevant parties to urgently facilitate a mission to West Papua by the High Commissioner for Human Rights.

Just like climate change and other pertinent challenges to our Blue Pacific, the COVID-19 pandemic must not hinder our efforts to address critical issues. 

Full statement    https://www.forumsec.org/2021/03/01/hrc46/



More troops have also been sent to West Papua causing fear in the local population.

 From a  Jubi report (22 February) “The more security personnel in Intan Jaya, the less secure the people will feel: Councilor”     

Residents of Intan Jaya Regency, Papua, seek safety at the front yard of Bilogai Catholic Church in Intan Jaya following armed conflicts. Jub/.Handout

Jayapura, Jubi – A Papua Legislative councilor from Intan Jaya electoral district, Thomas Sondegau, said the new deployment of security personnel to Intan Jaya would make residents in the regency more scared and worried about their safety. …    https://en.jubi.co.id/reduce-security-personnel-in-intan-jaya-councilor/



There has also been talk on dividing the territory into more provinces.

The politics of divide and rule and how Indonesia’s attempt to separate indigenous Papuans is an irrational and unrealistic proposal that will damage the cultural values of kinship and togetherness as Melanesian people, writes Dr Socratez Yoman.

An analysis by  Dr Socratez Yoman for the  Asia Pacific Report.

https://asiapacificreport.nz/2021/02/07/why-indonesias-planned-new-papuan-provinces-will-cause-division-and-destruction/


There have been large protests in the territory against any new provinces. A Jubi report (February 22, 2021) Thousands in Dogiyai rally in the street, rejecting new province, new police precinct” 

Thousands of people in Dogiyai rally to protest against the plan to create a new province in the regency. Jubi/Abeth You.  

Dogiyai, Jubi – Thousands of people in Dogiyai Regency in Papua, united under Papuan People Solidarity, took to the streets on Monday, Feb. 22, to protest against the government’s plan to create a new province and to establish a new police precinct at the regency level. They came from 11 districts in the regency and gathered in front of Dogiyai Legislative Council to convey their protests. Among the protesters were civil servants, Dogiyai Customary Council leaders, activists from West Papua National Committee (KNPB), students, customary figures, religious figures, and private company workers..... https://en.jubi.co.id/thousands-dogiyai-reject-new-province/

In Jayapura (from Jubi February 9, 2021) Jayapura, Jubi – Hundreds of university students from Lapago Customary Territory gathered on Monday in Jayapura, the capital of Papua province, to reject the central government and local administration plan to establish new provinces in Papua Land or West Papua.


Students hailing from Lapago Customary Territory rally in Jayapura on Feb. 8 to reject the plan to form new provinces in their customary area. Jubi/Yance Wenda


Also from Jubi February 16, 2021

‘It’s genocide’: Many Papuans reject new provinces. Here’s why.

A wave of rejections against Jakarta’s plan to establish new provinces in West Papua has emerged in Papua Land. Papuan students outside their home have also risen to the occasion and rejected the plan. One of the citizens who rejected the plan, Marius Goo, said there were several reasons native Papuans should reject the new provinces. Goo, who is an activist in Meepago customary territory, said it was “genocide” because he accused that the new provinces would bring more non-Papuans to Papua Land, sidelining native Papuans and in a long term, decimating them......  https://en.jubi.co.id/genocide-papua-new-provinces/


                                                   The map of Papua Land's customary territories.



Rally in Sorong calls on Jakarta to stop forcing Special Autonomy on Papua Suara Papua – January 13, 2021


Protesters in Sorong carry coffin with message ‘The death of Otsus in the land of Papua' – January 11, 2021 (SP)


Reiner Brabar, Kota Sorong – On Monday January 11, hundreds of protesters from the Papuan People's Front (FRP) who oppose the extension of Special Autonomy (Otsus) held a long-march from Kilometre 9 to the Sorong City Regional House of Representatives (DPRD) carrying a coffin with the message "The late Otsus". Action coordinator Marius Asso said, "The Papuan people in the land of the Cenderawasih have declared that they reject Special Autonomy", referring to the Bird of Paradise as Papuan is known.


According to Asso, 19 years of Special Autonomy in Papua has failed to protect or bring prosperity to indigenous Papuans, thus, he said, the Papuan people are united in rejecting Special Autonomy in Papua. "Jakarta, stop forcing the Papuan people to accept Otsus. We here are asking the people's representatives to convey to the Indonesian president that the Papua people are ready to bury Otsus which is already dead", he said. In addition to this, Asso called on the Sorong City DPRD to pass on their wishes to President Joko "Jokowi" Widodo in Jakarta. Another protesters, Apey Tarami, asserted that all of the demonstrators at today's action are asking the central government to immediately halt military operations in Papua and immediately withdraw troops from Nduga regency, Intan Jaya, and from throughout the land of Papua. "Papua is not a military operational zone", asserted Tarami.

 

The action was watched over by hundreds of police officers from the Sorong municipal police. Police attempted to stop the rally at one point but the protesters continued with the action.

The protesters were finally received by the speaker of the Sorong DPRD and after giving speeches and conveying their demands, they dispersed in an orderly fashion. 


The FRP made a number of demands of the DPRD including asking Jakarta to stop deliberations on the extension of Special Autonomy and to listen to the statements and demands of the Papuan people through the Papuan People's Petition opposing Special Autonomy, explicitly rejecting the continuation of Special Autonomy in Papua, that the Papuan people strongly condemn any parties that compromise with Jakarta on revisions to the Special Autonomy Law, that the Indonesian government immediately withdraw all organic and non-organic troops from Papua, for a halt to military operation in Nduga and throughout Papua and the closure of foreign investments in the land of Papua.

[Translated by James Balowski. The original title of the article was "Jakarta Stop Paksa Orang Papua Terima Otsus".] Source: https://suarapapua.com/2021/01/13/jakarta-stop-paksa-orang-papua-terima-otsus/

 

 


’Important’ for UN to visit West Papua in light of human rights issue: Dutch minister

 Jubi News Desk February 4, 2021 


Discussion of human rights issues in Tanah Papua must hold in Papua, illustration - Jubi/doc

 

 

Jakarta, Jubi – Dutch Foreign Affairs Minister Stef Blok told the Dutch parliament recently that the country considered a visit by United Nations (UN) High Commissioner for Human Rights to Papua “important”.

The statement was made on Jan. 12 in response to nine questions from seven political parties in the Netherlands. Seven out of nine questions concerned West Papua in a follow up to a hearing in November last year, in which the Dutch Foreign Affairs Committee of the House of Representatives listened to Benny Wenda, a West Papuan exiled leader.

 

“The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights has not yet visited Papua, partly because a visit has become temporarily virtually impossible due to the corona crisis. She does have a standing invitation to visit Indonesia. The Dutch Permanent Representation to the UN discussed this with the cabinet of the High Commissioner for Human Rights on Dec. 3. The Netherlands has indicated that it considers a visit by the High Commissioner for Human Rights to Papua important. The Netherlands will again indicate to the Indonesian authorities at the next opportunity that it is important that such a visit takes place as soon as possible,” Blok wrote in the document.

 

The current UN High Commissioner for Human Rights is Michelle Bachelet, a Chilean politician from the Socialist Party of Chile who served as the president of Chile from 2006-2010 and from 2014 to 2018. The other six questions from the Dutch parliament to Minister Stef Blok included issues pertaining to increasing rejection against the continuation of special autonomy funds, the shooting of Pastor Yeremia Zanambani, and the restriction of foreign journalists.

 

On Nov. 4, Nigel Adams, UK government Minister for Asia at the Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office (FCDO) who is also a member of parliament from Conservative Party, answered a question from a member of parliament about West Papua.

 

 

Adams’s answer was: “The UK supports a visit by the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights (ONHCR) to Papua. Officials from the British Embassy have discussed the proposed visit of with the Indonesian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and continue to encourage the Indonesian Government to agree dates as soon as possible.”

 

The international pressure on Indonesian government to invite UN High Commissioner for Human Rights to visit West Papua, a restive region that applies restricted access to foreign journalists, has been increasing especially in December 2019 when 79 countries in African Caribbean Pacific group made a resolution in which the countries “called for an international mission to visit Papua and provide an evidence-based, informed report on the human rights situation there,” reported RNZ Pacific.

 

 

Earlier in September 2019, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Michelle Bachelet said her office was “disturbed” by escalating violence in Papua and West Papua in the past two weeks, especially the deaths of some protestors and security forces.

 In early December 2020, the Southeast Asian branch of the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) expressed concern over the conflict in Papua Land. “We are disturbed by escalating violence over the past weeks and months […] and the increased risk of renewed tension and violence,” UN Human Rights Office spokeswoman Ravina Shamdasani said.

 

Human rights activists have called on the UN to visit the Papua Land to address the allegation of human rights violations, including alleged judicial killings and alleged gross human rights violations in Paniai Regency.

 

In February 2018, UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Zeid Ra’ad al Hussein visited Indonesia and raised concerns about human rights violations, among others, in Papua. Zeid, however, was barred a visit to West Papua.

 

In June 2018, Zeid said that the Indonesian government did not “honor” the promise for him to visit Papua Land. Permanent representative of Indonesia to UN, Hasan Kleib, responded with strong words that the Indonesian did not give access because of Zeid’s failure to “coordinate”.

 

 

Kleib confirmed that “my government has indeed invited him personally to visit the Indonesian provinces of Papua and West Papua to have a first-hand information on the ongoing improvements of human rights as well as the existing challenges.”

 

“In the follow-up, it is deeply regrettable that the staff members of his Regional Office in Bangkok, instead of coordinating the planned visit with the Indonesian authorities, has unilaterally set the dates and areas to visit in Papua and West Papua, while demanding immediate access,” wrote Kleib. Kleib said next time UN High Commissioner wanted to visit Papua, they should “strictly abide by the established working method of the UN, and respect the principles of consent of the host Government in its future engagement.”

 Editor: Evi Mariani

 


West Papua Liberation Movement condemns racist slurs

RNZI 29 January 2021 

 

The United Liberation Movement of West Papua has condemned more racist slurs directed at West Papuans from members of Indonesia's elite.

Two incidents have provoked fresh outrage, with at least one case prompting Indonesian police to make an arrest before public anger spills over. Last month a former head of the Indonesian intelligence agency and special forces, General Hendropriyono, said that West Papuans should be resettled away from their homeland on the island of Manado. He explained that the idea to move two million West Papuans was so Indonesia "could racially separate them from Papuans in PNG, so that they could feel more like Indonesians instead of foreigners". And in the past week, the chairman of a support network for Indonesian President Joko Widodo called a leading West Papuan human rights defender a "monkey". Ambronicus Nababan, who is chair of the Pro Jokowi-Amin Volunteers (Projamin), made the racial remark about Natalius Pigai, a Papuan who is a former chairman of Indonesia's National Human Rights Commission.

The "monkey" epithet is the same slur that triggered mass anti-racism protests across Papua region in 2019. Nababan has now been arrested and charged over the remarks he directed towards Pigai, according to police.

 

 

The Liberation Movement's leader Benny Wenda said that since Indonesian troops invaded Papua in 1963, Jakarta's elites had made clear their racist plans to destroy Melanesian West Papuans as a distinct people.

In response to Hendropriyono's remarks, Wenda noted it as a viewpoint with currency among elements of Indonesia's leadership. "This is racial ethnic cleansing, a genocidal fantasy at the highest levels of the Indonesian state," Wenda said. He said the remarks stood in a long tradition.

"When Indonesia invaded our land, General Ali Moertopo said the Papuan people should be transferred to the moon," Wenda said in the statement.

Wenda said racism has been at the heart of Indonesia's settler colonial project in West Papua. He said this was why the Liberation Movement established a provisional government for a prospective independent West Papua in December last year. Wenda is its interim president. "My people rose up against this racism and colonisation in 2019. Thousands of students returned from the rest of Indonesia in an exodus from racism, dozens were killed by Indonesia, and hundreds arrested. "The Indonesian state punished those who spoke out with over 100 years of collective prison time. The killers and racists in the army, police and state-backed militias were allowed to go free.”

 

Meanwhile, UCA News reports that Nababan apologised to Pigai. He said he didn't intend to make racist remarks against Papuan people but only wanted to criticise Pigai's reported opposition to a Covid-19 vaccine. In the case ofd the retired Indonesian general has also recently spoken out against alleged use of missionaries and churches in efforts to liberate Papua from Indonesia. However Hendropriyono’s comments about removing West Papuans from their homeland have met with outrage not just in Papua but in other parts of the Pacific.

 


KNPB activist denied proper medical treatment in police detention: Lawyer

Jubi News Desk February 11,  West Papua No. 1 News Portal | Jubi

 

Jayapura, Jubi – Papua Legal Aid Institute (LBH Papua) Director Emanuel Gobay, said that Merauke Police had denied 13 activists from the West Papua National Committee (KNPB) their right to health after the institute received a report that one of the detainees was critically ill. He said the family of Kristian Yandum informed him that Yandum was in Merauke Navy Hospital but they claimed he did not get proper treatment. Gobay said Yandum was allegedly beaten by the police officer when they arrested him along with 12 other KNPB activists on Dec. 13 last year. “Yandum’s family saw him in the hospital in a weak condition. He got oxygen tube attached to him but no IV drip,” said Gobay to Jubi on Thursday, Feb. 11, 2021. Gobay claimed the Merauke Police did not bring Yandum to the hospital fast enough. He said Yandum had been ill in Merauke Police detention center for days. Gobay said some other detained KNPB activists were also injured but did not get any treatment.

 

“Looking at the condition of the detainees, we had asked the police officers to fulfill the detainees’ right to health, in line with article 58 of the Criminal Procedure Law,” he said. On Jan. 13, LBH Papua sent a letter to the police to move Yandum to a health facility. “But they took time responding to our request,” he said. The police responded on Feb. 8, when they took Yandum to the Navy hospital at night. The last time the family checked on Feb. 11, Yandum was still in the emergency ward of the hospital. Gobay said Merauke Police also sent a letter to the lawyers, saying that Yandum was scheduled for an X-Ray examination on Feb. 10.One of the KNPB leaders at the headquarters, Marpo Wetipo, told Jubi that torture, being sick in detention center, and even death were the consequences of the activists who were facing “colonial administration”. “This is proof of colonialism. The proof that a systematic killing is happening. KNPB is fighting against this violent system with peace,” he said.  Wetipo said Indonesian government should have been ashamed of themselves that they fought peaceful fighting with violence, considering Indonesia had ratified several covenants on human rights. Coalition of Law and Human Rights Enforcers Papua released a report made available to Jubi on Feb. 11. The coalition claimed that the National Police’s Mobile Brigade (Brimob) personnel came to the office of KNPB Almasuh chapter in Merauke Regency on Dec. 13, riding two cars.

 


Indonesia’s Papuan bishops urge a future of hope for their people 

Vatican News  27 February 2021  By Robin Gomes

 The bishops of the neighbouring provinces of Papua and West Papua recently met to analyze the situation and problems affecting their people. The region is plagued by violence fueled by an armed struggle for independence. The Catholic bishops of Indonesia’s easternmost Provinces of West Papua and Papua are urging a “better future” from the country’s authorities for their people in a territory torn by decades of struggle between Indonesian forces and separatist groups.

 

Seek the common good

Representatives of the five dioceses of the two provinces recently came together for a 3-day meeting to discuss several problems affecting the Papuan people and their land, AsiaNews reported.  Among the issues they focused on were the territory’s special autonomy law (UU Otsus), new job and development opportunities, and improving education, which now represents an emergency that must be tackled right away.   The Catholic Church in West Papua and Papua consists of the single ecclesiastical metropolitan province of Merauke, which includes the Archdiocese of Merauke and the suffragan dioceses of Jayapura, Agats, Timika and Manokwari-Sorong. The see of Timika is currently vacant. In a press release on 25 Feb., at the end of their meeting, the Church leaders appealed to the country’s national and local leaders, urging them to focus on the common good of the people. According to them, peace can only be achieved through dialogue and an end to the armed struggle by separatist groups.


Struggle for independence

Indonesia’s military and security forces are pitted against local pro-independence armed groups who are pushing for “a referendum on self-determination”. 

The bishops urged both sides to adopt “an approach based on love and non-violence”, inviting them to realize the “importance of peaceful dialogue”.  Instead of discussing the further implementation of the special autonomy that has been in place for 20 years and which expires in 2021, they want to see the parties “get back to work together.”

Indigenous residents of West Papua and are Papua ethnically similar. The two provinces became part of Indonesia controversially in the 1960s, despite the former Dutch colony declaring independence in 1961.  Since then, a separatist movement has been simmering in Papua, with sporadic violence.  People have been complaining of discrimination and rights abuses at the hands of Indonesian authorities.

The prospects for peace are still conditioned by the armed struggle, which has led over the years to extrajudicial killings and violence on both sides. The civilians have suffered the most, forced to flee and seek refuge wherever they can, even inside churches.


Economic development and education

The bishops of the two Papuan provinces are stressing the need for creating a future of hope for their people through opportunities for economic development through jobs and encouraging local businesses and enterprises.  The bishops complain that local businesses are owned by on-Papuan migrants from other provinces. “Regency officials,” they said, “should instead create opportunities for indigenous people, giving them the necessary skills and means.”

Another emergency, they said, is education which has been negatively impacted recently by the coronavirus pandemic. With school absenteeism normally high, the pandemic has exacerbated the situation, making illiteracy a serious problem. “When the bases of primary education are inadequate, one cannot hope to achieve anything better from high school or universities,” the bishops said.  (Source: AsiaNews)

 




 

Lay Papuans turn against Indonesian Church deal with palm oil firm

By Ryan Dagur, 18 February 2021

 Activists stage protest against Archbishop of Merauke signing deal with palm oil firm “at expense of environment” Together with several colleagues, Papuan Catholic activist Melvin Waine stood in front of Good Shepherd Parish Church in Abepura, Papua province, on Jan. 31. There was a box in front of them and they were holding up posters appealing for donations. “One thousand rupiah for Bishop Mandagi,” the posters said, referring to Archbishop Petrus Canisius Mandagi of Merauke. However, their effort was not in support of the bishop; it was a sarcastic stunt criticising Archbishop Mandagi.

 

The local Church is set to receive billions of rupiah after signing a memorandum of understanding (MoU) with a controversial palm oil company, PT Tunas Sawa Erma, part of the Korindo Group. The funds raised will be presented to the Diocese of Merauke. “The archbishop shouldn’t be cooperating with this firm. It’s scandalous that the Church conspires with a company that has brought suffering to Papua,” Waine told UCA News. He said they collected 882,000 rupiah (US$63) from supporters who attended Sunday Mass in Abepura Parish and two other parishes. “We will continue this at other churches every Sunday. We are also preparing to collect online,” he said. Their aim, he said, was for the archdiocese to cancel the MoU, signed on Jan. 5, in which the company committed to providing 2.4 billion rupiah, which is given in stages over three years. The company will also give the archdiocese operational cost 20 million rupiah a month for three years. Archbishop Mandagi has said the archdiocese needs to raise money, including from palm oil companies, to fund services including the construction of a minor seminary. He said the Church still expects the company to adopt environmentally sustainable practices.

 

However, for Waine, what the archbishop has done has aided the destruction of Papua’s forests, which the Korindo Group, a joint Indonesian and South Korean venture, has been accused of doing.

“It would be better for the money to have been collected from the people rather than companies that are clearly bringing suffering to Papuans,” Waine said. Petrus Supardi, another layman, said that “Archbishop Mandagi has rubbed salt in the wounds of Papuans.” “How do you set up a seminary, an educational centre for future church leaders, by collaborating with companies that destroy Papua’s natural forests?” he asked.

 

Among the religious themselves, this cooperation is equally controversial.

Father Alexandro Rangga, a Franciscan priest from Papua who is studying in Rome, said he cannot stop thinking that the Church now supports palm oil companies. “The Church must be firm in rejecting palm oil. We already know the impacts and that is always the poor who are the biggest victim,” he said in a recent webinar organised by the Franciscan Commission for Justice, Peace and Integrity of Creation (JPIC).

 

In November, Greenpeace Indonesia and Forensic Architecture reported that Dongin Prabhawa, one of Korindo’s subsidiaries, had destroyed 57,000 hectares of rainforest, based on forest fires captured on NASA satellite imagery between 2011 and 2016. In “Burning Paradise,” a report released in 2016, environmental group Mighty Earth also pointed to Korindo’s systematic and abundant use of fire during land clearing. Sacred Heart Father Anselmus Amo, chairman of Merauke Archdiocese’s JPIC Commission, did not respond to UCA News’ request for comment. However, speaking to local media, he criticised the laymen’s actions and asked them not to doubt the agreement, stating that the archdiocese would not cancel it. “Whether the bishop will accept [the money they collect] is up to the archbishop. The point is we should not think negatively [of the cooperation],” he said, as quoted by the Papua Selatan Pos newspaper. Archbishop Mandagi is currently hospitalised in Ambon, Maluku province, after being diagnosed with COVID-19 on Jan. 29.

 

Voices grow louder

The protesters also issued a statement last month in which they declared they had lost trust in bishops from Papua and the Indonesian Bishops’ Conference, whom they accused of not caring about Papuan issues.

They added that the Vatican should consider appointing native Papuans, or at least those who understand the situation in Papua, as bishops in Indonesia’s easternmost region. “We need those who care about the local situation, especially regarding human rights violations and environmental damage,” they said. They said that they no longer felt that the Catholic Church offered hope for salvation. Waine, who participated in drawing up the statement, said they represented lay groups from five dioceses in Papua. “We have formulated this call after reflecting together on the recent development of the Church,” he said. “We are forced to do this, so that the Church will return to its mission, to its calling to be the voice of the voiceless.” Marthen Goo from Papua Itu Kita (Papua Is Us), a Jakarta-based advocacy forum, said the opposition is something that the Church must take seriously. “The protestations of this lay group are an expression of despair because they principally see the Church as the last bastion in the face of humanitarian problems that occur,” he said.

The Church must reposition and totally evaluate itself so that it once again is a church of the oppressed. “The Church is better off living in poverty and speaking out for God’s people rather than prioritising money while allowing people to be threatened,” Goo said.  Reproduced with permission from La Croix International




Opinion pieces/reports/media releases etc.


DFAT reply to AWPA letter of the 28 November 2020




Can the Pacific Become a Priority for Indonesian Diplomacy?

https://thediplomat.com/2021/02/can-the-pacific-become-a-priority-for-indonesian-diplomacy/



New report details numerous violations by PT Freeport Indonesia in West Papua 

SPECIAL REPORT PT Freeport Indonesia and its tail of violations in Papua: human, labour and environmental rights December 2020

 

https://www.humanrightspapua.org/news/32-2020/716-new-report-details-numerous-violations-by-pt-freeport-indonesia-in-west-papua

Full report     https://www.humanrightspapua.org/images/docs/PT_Freeport_Indo_tail_of_violations_in_Papua_Dec20.pdf 





Infrastructure Idols: Portraits and Paradigms of Development under Special Autonomy in Papua














https://elsam.or.id/infrastructure-idols-portraits-and-paradigms-of-development-under-special-autonomy-in-papua/







Papua tribe moves to block clearing of its ancestral forest for palm oil

by The Gecko Project and Mongabay on 21 January 2021

https://news.mongabay.com/2021/01/papua-tribe-moves-to-block-clearing-of-its-ancestral-forest-for-palm-oil/



 

Papua deforestation highlights eastward shift of Indonesia forest clearing












Villagers in Boven Digoel Regency stand on a deforested area. Courtesy of Auriga Nusantara.

Photo in Jubi  article 2 March

 


Papua’s Morning Star in Australian communities: Notes from a national holiday celebration 

https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2021/02/11/papuas-morning-star-in-australian-communities-notes-from-a-national-holiday-celebration.html



‘A cancer at the heart of the UN’: Indonesia’s escalating West Papua conflict



(Note. Lots of images  in article).

Australia, UK and UN dragged into information operations targeting West Papua

22 Dec 2020| Ariel Bogle and Albert Zhang    Strategist special report

https://www.aspistrategist.org.au/australia-uk-and-un-dragged-into-information-operations-targeting-west-papua/


Spatial access to health care: a case study on community health centers in Asmat District, Papua, Indonesia   January 2021Journal of Public Health Policy 

1) Statement to the High Level Segment of the 46th Session of the Human Rights Council (COVID-19, Climate Change, West Papua)


2) Papua deforestation highlights eastward shift of Indonesia forest clearing
3) Indonesian police chief accused of ‘murder’ of peaceful West Papuan activist

—————————————




COVID-19, Climate Change, West Papua- Forum SG statement to the high level segment of the 46th session of the UN Human Rights Council

https://www.forumsec.org/2021/03/01/hrc46/

Pacific Islands Forum Secretary General
1) Statement to the High Level Segment of the 46th Session of the Human Rights Council

24th February 2021

Madam President,  Excellencies,  Ladies and Gentlemen.

Thank you for the opportunity to deliver a statement on behalf of the Pacific Islands Forum Secretariat.

The Pacific Islands Forum brings together 18 Member states to protect the people, place, and prospects of our Blue Pacific Continent.

My statement today will highlight three Forum Leaders’ priorities – COVID-19 response and recovery; the climate change crisis; and human rights in West Papua (Papua).


COVID-19

Your Excellencies, Forum Leaders have recognised COVID-19 as a major crisis for our Blue Pacific region and are deeply concerned about its effects across the globe.

Our Member States acted quickly to restrict the spread of COVID-19, putting in place exceptional national response measures and establishing the Pacific Humanitarian Pathway on COVID-19.

While such swift action resulted in a relatively low rate of infection across the region, it severely restricted our links to each other, and the world, with devastating socio-economic impacts.

Indeed, the Pacific region is said to have contracted by an unprecedented 6.1 per cent last year. Major job losses and plummeting incomes are resulting in family and community hardship, with poverty, hunger and malnutrition increasing. Gender based violence, which is already a major challenge for our region, is on the rise.

Today, the health and wellbeing of Pacific peoples, and our Ocean, remain our greatest priority.

Forum Leaders have called for a coordinated and sustained COVID-19 recovery in the Pacific – working through national and regional systems to protect the vulnerable, support economic livelihoods and ‘build back better’.

An example of a Pacific led solution is the Pacific Resilience Facility, which seeks to provide small grants to communities to build their resilience towards climate and disaster risks, including pandemics.

Our Forum Leaders have also called on global leaders to support the equitable and affordable distribution of safe and effective COVID-19 treatments and vaccines to all peoples.

In addition, Forum Leaders have called for support to build quality health infrastructure and systems. For the Pacific, this is important in the fight against communicable and non-communicable diseases.

We call on the Human Rights Council to ensure no one is left behind in rebuilding from COVID-19, and that all Members have the right to access medical supplies and vaccines at affordable prices.


Climate Change

While COVID-19 is our immediate crisis, Forum Leaders have reaffirmed climate change as the single greatest threat to our region.

Currently at 1.2 degree Celsius of global warming, our sea levels are rising, our ocean is warming, and more frequent and extreme weather events are inflicting damage and destruction. Indeed, four category 5 cyclones have hit our region since 2015 , and just this year, three cyclones have already wreaked havoc in Fiji.

Between 2008 and 2019, more than 616,000 new displacements have been recorded across the Pacific, from a total of 97 disaster events .

Recognising the urgency, Forum Leaders issued their strongest collective statement on climate change action in 2019 – the Kainaki II Declaration for Urgent Climate Change Action Now.

The declaration recognises that the prosperity and security of our Blue Pacific can only safely exist if the international community pursues efforts to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees.

It calls on partners to join with the Blue Pacific in taking bold, decisive, and transformative climate change action.

Despite the fact that the climate crisis has cross-cutting impacts and requires urgent attention, there is no dedicated mechanism at the Human Rights Council.

Last year, our Forum Foreign Ministers endorsed the establishment of a Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and Climate Change.

Today, I reiterate the call of our Forum Foreign Ministers, and encourage the Human Rights Council to act swiftly and decisively to establish a Special Rapporteur on Human Rights and Climate Change.


West Papua (Papua)

Excellencies, the violent conflict and subsequent human rights violations in West Papua (Papua) has been a concern for the Pacific Island Forum Leaders for over 20 years. In 2016, it become a standing agenda item for Forum Leaders.

Pacific Island Forum Leaders’ focus on West Papua has been squarely on human rights – calling on all parties to protect and uphold the human rights of all residents, and to work to address the root causes of the conflict by peaceful means.

In recent years, the escalation of tension and alleged human rights violations on both sides of the conflict, particularly against innocent civilians, has deepened the collective concerns of the Leaders of the Pacific.

When our Leaders met in Tuvalu two years ago, they welcomed the invitation by the Government of Indonesia for a mission to West Papua by the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, and strongly encouraged both sides to finalise the timing of the visit. Leaders also called for an evidence-based report on the situation in West Papua to be provided before their next meeting.

We call on distinguished Council Members to encourage all relevant parties to urgently facilitate a mission to West Papua by the High Commissioner for Human Rights.

Just like climate change and other pertinent challenges to our Blue Pacific, the COVID-19 pandemic must not hinder our efforts to address critical issues.

I thank you.

FIJI STATEMENT Read Watch

Hon.  Josaia Voreqe Bainimarama, CF (Mil),OStJ,MSD,JSSC,PSC, Prime Minister and Minister for iTaukei Affairs, Sugar Industry, and Foreign Affairs

MARSHALL ISLANDS STATEMENT Read Watch

H.E.  Casten N. Nemra, Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade of the Marshall Islands

NEW ZEALAND STATEMENT  Read Watch

Hon. Ms. Nanaia Mahuta, Minister for Foreign Affairs of New Zealand

PACIFIC FORUM STATEMENT Read Watch

Dame Meg Taylor, Secretary General of the Pacific Islands Forum

PACIFIC COMMUNITY STATEMENT Read Watch

Stuart Minchin, Director General of the Pacific Community




——————————



https://news.mongabay.com/2021/03/papua-deforestation-highlights-eastward-shift-of-indonesia-forest-clearing/

2) Papua deforestation highlights eastward shift of Indonesia forest clearing
by  on 1 March 2021

  • Deforestation is increasing in forest-rich regions in Indonesia, even as the government claims the national average has gone down, a new report shows.
  • The NGOs behind the report attribute the decline in the national deforestation rate to the fact that there’s virtually no forest left to clear in parts of Sumatra and Borneo.
  • Instead, deforestation has moved east, largely to the Papua region, home to nearly two-fifths of Indonesia’s remaining rainforest — an area the size of Florida — where companies are clearing land for oil palm and pulpwood plantations and mines.
  • Another key driver of the deforestation in Papua is infrastructure development, which the government claims is meant to connect remote villages and communities, but which really serve mines, plantations and logging concessions, the report shows.

JAKARTA — Forests in parts of Indonesia regions that have remained largely untouched are now fast disappearing as deforestation driven by agribusiness and infrastructure development moves east, according to a new report.

Using deforestation data from the University of Maryland’s Global Land Analysis and Discovery (GLAD) data set and land cover maps from the Ministry of Environment and Forestry, the report by a coalition of 11 Indonesian NGOs looks at the trend of forest clearing across Indonesia in the past two decades.

It found that while the annual deforestation rate has been decreasing over the past decade nationally, 10 provinces with relatively abundant forest cover have seen their individual rates increasing.

From 2010 to 2014, there were 1.8 million hectares (4.4 million acres) of deforestation in these 10 provinces; from 2015 to 2019, the rate increased to 1.85 million hectares (4.5 million acres). Meanwhile, the national deforestation rate dropped from 3.4 million hectares (8.4 million acres) in 2010-2014, to 2.81 million hectares (6.9 million acres) in 2015-2019.

These 10 provinces — Papua, West Papua, Central Kalimantan, East Kalimantan, North Kalimantan, West Kalimantan, Central Sulawesi, Aceh, Maluku and North Maluku — hold 80% of Indonesia’s 88 million hectares (217.4 million acres) of remaining forest cover.


Dedy Sukmara, a researcher at the environmental NGO Auriga, a member of the coalition behind the report, said looking at deforestation trends by region rather than nationally is important because it gives a clearer picture of what’s happening with the country’s forests.

“We can’t [just] see the deforestation rate nationally because in the past five years, the number has been declining, but the deforestation rate in forest-rich provinces has tended to spike,” he said. “So there’s a possibility that the [national] deforestation rate is going down because there’s no more forest to be cleared in the other provinces.”

He cited the case of Riau province on the island of Sumatra, where the forests have been almost completely cleared for large-scale pulpwood and oil palm plantations.

According to the report, the deforestation rate in Riau plunged by 81%, with 715,000 hectares (1.76 million acres) cleared in 2015-2019 compared to the previous five years. The decline here and in other provinces where there’s virtually no forest left to clear is enough to drag down the national average, enabling the government to claim that it has succeeded in curbing deforestation through its own policies and actions, according to Mufthi Fathul Barri, a researcher with Forest Watch Indonesia (FWI).

As a result of this claim, Indonesia has received plaudits from the international community for ostensibly making progress on reducing its greenhouse gas emissions, the biggest source of which is deforestation and land use change. The U.N.’s Green Climate Fund, for instance, has approved a $103.8 million payment to Indonesia for preventing deforestation-based carbon emissions — its biggest payout to any country.

“If [we] take a closer look [at the data], it [declining deforestation] isn’t caused by the government’s performance in curbing [deforestation], but because forest resources in regions with lots of forestry permits have already been exhausted,” Mufthi said. “On Sumatra and Borneo, they’re largely gone.”

And with large tracts of land becoming increasingly scarce on those two islands, the same agribusiness companies that cleared the forests there are now eyeing the eastern islands of Indonesia, particularly the Papua region.

This region — comprising the western half of the island of New Guinea and split administratively between the provinces of Papua and West Papua — is home to 38% of Indonesia’s remaining rainforest. This amounts to 33.8 million hectares (83.5 million acres) of forests, an area the size of Florida — and it’s here where the biggest jump in deforestation is happening, according to the NGOs’ report.

Over the past two decades, the Papua region has lost 663,443 hectares (1.6 million acres) of natural forest cover; 71% of this deforestation occurred from 2011 to 2019. The highest annual rate was in 2015, when 89,881 hectares (222,100 acres) of forest was cleared.

“When there’s a claim of decline in deforestation in Indonesia, that doesn’t mean anything when 80% of it is happening in Papua,” Mufthi said. “Why? Because we’re an archipelagic country. Deforestation should been interpreted in more detail” than the national average.



Papua, the final frontier

Papua’s remoteness — it’s largest city, Jayapura, is two time zones and more than five hours by plane from the capital, Jakarta — and dearth of infrastructure such as roads, electricity, telecommunications and piped water have long rendered the region the least developed and most impoverished in Indonesia.

On the flipside, though, it has meant the rich forests of Papua, one of most biodiverseregions on the planet, have stayed largely out of reach of the agribusiness and mining outfits that have ravaged the forests of Sumatra and Kalimantan.

But that’s changed in recent years, thanks to a renewed government focus on boosting development in the region. Palm oil companies have begun moving in, quickly mowing down vast swaths of some of Indonesia’s last pristine forests.

2017 study by Duke University and the International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis showed that deforestation driven by oil palm expansion in the region had increased fivefold in the past decade.

The coalition report also shows that oil palm expansion is a major contributor to deforestation in Papua, with government-issued licenses making the deforestation legal.

The so-called forestry conversion licenses are issued by the Ministry of Environment and Forestry to degazette forest areas — where plantations and mines aren’t allowed — into non-forest zones, which can then be cleared and converted.

Satellite image analysis of these release areas for oil palm plantation development reveal that, in 2019, areas under such licenses saw 145,595 hectares (359,000 acres) of deforestation, or almost one-third of all the deforestation in the Papua region.

The Ministry of Environment and Forestry, in responding to the NGOs’ report, tried to deflect by saying almost all the deforestation in the Papua region stems from permits issued before President Joko Widodo took office in 2014. It added that the forestry conversion permits issued under the current administration were based on recommendations from local community leaders.

FWI’s Mufthi said blaming the previous past administrations achieves nothing.

“Regardless of who’s the president and the minister, the fact is that deforestation in Papua keeps happening at an increasing rate,” he said. “It’s very unethical if government institutions blame each other, especially if it’s still the same ministry. Most officials working in the forestry ministry today also worked in it under the previous administration.”


Infrastructure as driver of deforestation

While oil palm has historically been the major driver of deforestation in Indonesia, today it’s not the only one, Mufthi said. Infrastructure development is another factor, and one that’s being pushed heavily by the Widodo administration, he said.

He pointed to a near-doubling of the deforestation rate in Papua’s mountainous hinterland from 2013-2018, compared to the previous five-year period. “Our prediction is that this is caused by road development, infrastructure projects, etc.,” Mufthi said. “They indirectly contribute to deforestation that’s happening in Papua. Mountainous areas are started to get encroached on because road access is being opened little by little.”

2020 report by FWI cited the case of Tambrauw district in West Papua province, which has seen a web of road projects spring up in recent years. The district government has declared Tambrauw a conservation district, with the aim of protecting its remaining forest. But road projects being pushed by the national and provincial governments are eating away at these forests.

And while the publicly stated rationale for building new roads is to connect remote villages and settlements, in many cases the new roads serve the mines, plantations and logging concessions dotted across the Papua region. The report shows how two roads in northern Tambrauw — an existing one and a planned one — provide easier access for logging companies already operating there to truck out their wood.

“Meanwhile, the road in the middle part of Tambrauw also passes plantation and mining concessions,” the report says. “And all planned airports and docks are located less than 5 kilometers [3 miles] away from concessions.”

Mufthi said this shows a clear continuity between the extractive activity licensed by the previous administration and the infrastructure projects licensed by the current administration to support that activity.

“During the administration of former president Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, there were many licenses issued [for agribusiness], especially in Papua,” he said. “Meanwhile, during Joko Widodo’s regime, there are many infrastructure developments to accommodate and support the needs of the companies that received licenses from Yudhoyono’s administration. So it’s very weird for fingers to be pointed when all these are connected.”


With deforestation showing no signs of slowing in Papua, Mufthi called on the government to learn from  past policy mistakes that led to the wholesale deforestation of Sumatra and Borneo.

“If we could project what will happen to Papua in the next two decades, just look at what’s happening in Sumatra and Kalimantan now,” he said. “Similar things are starting in Papua now and this is a warning for us all.”

He said the government should use all of the tools in its policy kit, including a moratorium on new permits to clear primary forests and peatlands, and another on establishing new oil palm plantations.

“If this situation can’t be improved, then what’s the use of the moratoriums?” he said. “This is a moment for all of us to think of what can be done in the future, not to deny and look for justification from facts that are happening.”

 

Banner image: Sulphur-crested Cockatoo (Cacatua galerita) in West Papua, Indonesia. Image by Rhett A. Butler/Mongabay.

 

FEEDBACK: Use this form to send a message to the author of this post. If you want to post a public comment, you can do that at the bottom of the page.

Article published by 
——————————-

https://morningstaronline.co.uk/article/w/indonesian-police-chief-accused-murder-peaceful-west-papuan-activist

3) Indonesian police chief accused of ‘murder’ of peaceful West Papuan activist

WEST Papuan independence advocates have accused Indonesian police chief Untung Sangaji of the torture and killing of peaceful activist Kristianus Yandum, who died on Saturday.

The National Committee for West Papua (KNPB) said Mr Yandum was among 13 of its members arrested on December 13 for merely sitting in front of its offices.

Mr Sangaji denied that the death occurred through torture and said Mr Yandum died in hospital from a congenital disease after receiving treatment there for several weeks.

“What should be noted is that while being treated at the hospital the person concerned was not even handcuffed, even though he was a prisoner,” the regional police chief said.

He said that those being held “were treasonous and had continued to spread propaganda,” but claimed that stories of detainees’ ill treatment were a hoax.

KNPB spokesman Victor Yeimo insisted that the prisoners had been tortured and demanded that Indonesia’s National Commission on Human Rights investigates.

“Untung Sangaji is a murderer responsible for the death of our friend Kristianus,” he said.

“We strongly condemn the actions of police chief Untung Sangaji and call for humanitarian solidarity and justice for the victims, as well as the unconditional release of our 12 friends still languishing in the Indonesian police compound,” he said.

He called for international pressure on Indonesian President Joko Widodo “to stop violence against KNPB peace activists and immediately take a peaceful political solution to the political conflict that continues to consume relentless casualties in the West Papua homeland.”

At least 500,000 people, mainly West Papuans, are believed to have been killed since the archipelago was formally annexed by Indonesia in 1969.

Just over 1,000 West Papuans were forced – often at gunpoint – to ratify rule by Jakarta by voting for the so-called Act of Free Choice.

———————-