1) Australia cannot ignore rights abuses in West Papua

2) Letters in media

------------------------------------

http://www.onlineopinion.com.au/view.asp?article=14785&page=0

1) Australia cannot ignore rights abuses in West Papua

By Rachael Bongiorno - posted Tuesday, 12 March 2013

The visit to Australia this past week of exiled West Papuan independence leader, Benny Wenda, has brought renewed attention to the deteriorating human rights situation in West Papua.

Wenda, now based in the UK, came to Australia as part of a global tour. His message is simple: The international community should respond to West Papua's cries for freedom.

West Papauns are seeking an end to the human rights abuses, an end to Indonesia's illegal occupation and an opening up of the province to foreign scrutiny by media and human rights organisations. Despite being one of our closest Melanesian neighbours, only around 300 km's north of Australia, many Australians have little knowledge of West Papua, its people, culture and history.

Wenda's visit has illuminated both Australia's role in supporting the 50-year colonisation, as well as our country's potential role in ameliorating it. As a country priding itself on upholding human rights - Australia has a moral, political and economic imperative to respond to West Papua's pleas.

Australia has consistently put its strategic interests ahead of recognising the rights of the West Papuans. In 1962 it was cold war fears encouraging Australia to support the effective transfer of West Papua from Dutch colonisation to Indonesian, through a U.S drafted treaty. It also supported the 1969 referendum that solidified the occupation- despite it being widely criticised as a sham vote.

The recent comments by our foreign affairs minister who stated, "both sides of Australian politics-fully recognised Indonesian sovereignty over the Papuan provinces"- demonstrates the legacy of this strategic support, which comes before any human rights concerns. However, as Jennifer Robinson, the human rights lawyer accompanying Wenda on his tour, pointed out - as a country which recently got a seat on the UN Security Council on account of its human rights based foreign policy, Australia cannot continue to ignore the human rights abuses on our doorstep.

It is estimated that as many as 500,000 Papuans have been killed since Indonesia took control. Research from the Centre for Peace and Conflict Studies at the University of Sydney has even questioned whether the situation for West Papuans constitutes genocide.

The Asian Human Rights Commission, Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International and Survival International continue to receive credible reports of human rights violations committed by the Indonesian forces. These accusations include torture, rape, extrajudicial killings, imprisonment and unnecessary and excessive use of force on peaceful demonstrators.

According to Independence leader, Victor Yeimo who is based in West Papua, in 2012 twenty-two young pro-independence activists were shot by Indonesian forces and a further fifty-five behind bars. Last week alone saw five activists, arrested and tortured, then released without charge.

It may come as a surprise to many Australians that this is not simply a remote and irrelevant conflict on the other side of the world. Apart from our geographic proximity, we are directly implicated in this occupation and these human rights abuses through our military and economic investments in the resource rich Papuan provinces.

Much of Indonesian and global interests in West Papua are based on its vast natural resources, exploited for Gold, Copper, Oil and logging- and to this, Australia is not immune. The largest contributor to Indonesia's GDP, their largest taxpayer and a significant source of revenue for the military is the Grasberg mine, the largest gold and copper mine in the world. Although this is owned by the U.S company Freeport McMoran, British-Australian Rio Tinto has a 60-40 joint venture agreement with Freeport, which entitles it to a significant share of production. With nearly all of Australia's financial institutions investing in Rio Tinto, we are implicated here too.

Additionally, Australia's tax payers money, through the AFP, helps provide financial and operational support to one of the sections of the Indonesian security forces, known as Detachment 88- even though these forces have been linked to crackdowns on independence movements in West Papua, including torture and extrajudicial killings.

While it is commendable, Australia's foreign minister called for an investigation into the killing of peaceful independence leader, Mako Tabuni, parliamentarians have still not received adequate information on this investigation through senate estimates requests.

Unfortunately, despite Wenda's calls for an end to Indonesia's illegal occupation and the grave human rights abuses, the foreign minister dismisses Australian support for West Papuan freedom as 'idealistic' and 'utterly inconceivable', fearing 'what it cost in terms of our friendship with Indonesia and in terms of our budget of a different arrangement.'

However, Jennifer Robinson acknowledges there are a number of things Australia could be doing, while respecting Indonesia's territorial integrity. This includes, pushing for greater access for journalists so that we know what's going on there, as well as raising a number of human rights concerns enshrined in the UN agreements to which Indonesia is a signatory.

Senator Richard Di Natale, who initiated the Australian chapter of International Parliamentarians for West Papua, said Wenda's visit gave these politicians a personal perspective of the issue and more fuel to continue the work they're doing in Parliament. Di Natale said he will support an international parliamentary delegation to visit West Papua, will continue to push for greater transparency in our military relationship with Indonesia, raise concerns of human rights abuses and push for a free and open press.

While the support from this group of politicians from across parties gives us hope, more public pressure is needed. For Wenda, connecting with the local West Papuan community in Australia and building awareness together, is one of the greatest tools we can use to put pressure on the government to break the silence on West Papua's injustice.

It took 24 years of bloody Indonesian occupation before Australia and the international community put its weight behind the referendum for East Timor's freedom. How much longer will West Papua have to wait?

Let's hope Benny Wenda's message to Australia will be heard.

-----------------------------------------------

2) Letters in media

http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2013/03/11/your-letters-uncertainty-west-papua.html

Your letters: Uncertainty in West Papua

The Jakarta Post | Readers Forum | Mon, March 11 2013, 10:47 AM

A- A A+

Paper Edition | Page: 8

If you were born during the 1990s or experienced the 1998 riots, looking at the rows of buses filled with angry civilians waving their flags crying for change, then you more-or-less saw and didn’t see the same things through the same lens as me.

Perhaps what we see isn’t as important as what we don’t see. After the fall of Soeharto and the New Order regime, Indonesia slowly turned from being a feudalistic, authoritarian country to a somewhat “democratic” one. The change that people had been waiting for had finally come, or so we believed.

We, the 1990s generation, were always told not to remember the sins of our fathers through the mass media. Our history textbooks only tell what the victors of history want to tell: the communist purge, Timor Leste, or any other site of state-sponsored violence and genocide. Not to mention the reasons they give us to justify the gory acts they committed on our Chinese-Indonesian brothers and neighbors; or how beautiful Bali is, until the ocean waves slowly wash away the sand that hides hundreds of graves of innocent men, women and unborn children.

West Papua is another perfect example. We are always told how primitive the Papuan people are; that we are the nobles in fine clothes while they are the koteka-wearing savages. We know that God created one of the most-stunning paradises on earth there, which we call Raja Ampat; that their land is rich in gold and natural resources. We are always told that not only do Papuans wear koteka (penile guards) but that they also harbor life-threatening separatists, and we are always told the number of soldiers killed by the OPM (Free Papua Movement).

But what we’ve never been told is that Papuans are also human. We have never been told how they struggle for their lives; how they fight for their land and trees, to prevent some multinational corporation from raping them; how they honor nature and their ancestors. We have never been told their history; how they fought for their independence from the Dutch in 1961; how their fathers were threatened at gunpoint to vote in support of Indonesia’s occupation in the 1969 “Act of Free Choice”. We never knew the number of Papuan men that were shot in the head, or the number of women raped by our noble state military men in front of their own families in open fields, or how their children carry inerasable scars of trauma.

So who’s to blame for this confusion? Who should we believe? Which “truth” should we seek? Perhaps it is a truth that we only see what we want to see. That we’re born ignorant and will die in ignorance. Thus, to draw upon what history said about the RMS Titanic, our great “nation” will sail bravely to the “great perhaps” and sink in cinematic and obsolete nature, caused by our own iceberg of ignorance.

Poska Ariadana
Oita, Japan

---------------------------------------

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/opinion/letters/carrs-view-of-west-papua/story-fn558imw-1226595012655

Carr's view of West Papua

From:The Australian
March 12, 2013 12:00AM

FOREIGN Minister Bob Carr says that it would be "cruel" for Indonesia to keep Schapelle Corby in jail under conditions "somewhat different" to those that would apply in Australia ("Corby jail time cruel: Carr", 11/3).

It is to Carr's credit that he is prepared to speak out on behalf of Corby and even more to his credit that he speaks out in defence of the Kurds, Coptic Christians and other minority groups that are under attack.

It is, however, to his discredit that while he is fully aware of Indonesia's crimes against humanity in West Papua, including imprisoning people for their political beliefs, he is not prepared to take a principled stance against the occupation and oppression there.

Carr has repeatedly stated that West Papua is simply a restive province of Indonesia and that Indonesia is behaving in a restrained and acceptable manner.

For a quarter of a century we stood by and watched East Timor suffer under the most terrible Indonesian tyranny before finally biting the bullet and helping the East Timorese to liberate and rebuild their country. It is time we took the same stance in defence and support of the West Papuan people.

Bill Anderson, Surrey Hills, Vic

AWPA Sydney

Monday, March 11, 2013