Saturday, February 3, 2018

1) AJI slams ‘expulsion’ of BBC journalists from Papua

2) Asian rights body calls for more action by Jakarta over Papuan health crisis


1) AJI slams ‘expulsion’ of BBC journalists from Papua
News Desk The Jakarta Post
Jakarta | Sat, February 3, 2018 | 05:57 pm
The Alliance of Independent Journalists (AJI) has criticized the government for banning three BBC Indonesia journalists from reporting on a measles and malnutrition outbreak in Papua because of the tweets posted by one of them.  
Australian journalist reporting for BBC Indonesia, Rebecca Henschke, was told to leave Papua after she posted several tweets criticizing the provision of aid. She posted a picture, showing boxes of food and drinks on a dock, captioned “This is the aid coming in for severely malnourished children in Papua- instant noodles, super sweet soft drinks and biscuits.”
The Indonesian Military (TNI), which is taking part in the health mission in Asmat, claimed that “what she wrote did not reflect the truth. In the photo, [the food and drinks] were not humanitarian aid, but products sold by merchants and accidentally placed [on the dock].”
Immigration Directorate General spokesperson Agung Sampurno said in his written statement Henschke’s tweets were offensive not only to the government but also to Indonesian people, as well as marring to journalism as a profession.


Seorang Jurnalis asing dari media BBC telah membuat berita tidak sesuai fakta soal penanganan warga Asmat di Papua. Jurnalis itu bernama Rebecca Alice Henschke dan berkewarganegaraan Australia. Dia menulis tentang kiprah TNI yang dianggapnya kurang sesuai dan hanya memberikan bantuan ala kadarnya semacam roti dan biskuit. Secara tidak langsung ini sudah mengarah pada pemberitaan yang tidak benar, TNI disana bersama seluruh komponen lainnya all out bahkan beberapa kali mengirimkan tim medis untuk melakukan penanganan langsung. Bantuan yang diberikan juga tidak hanya sekedar roti dan biskuit tapi lebih dari itu. Apa yang disampaikan oleh Rebecca ini sudah melukai perasaan warga Asmat dan TNI yang bertugas disana serta semua pihak yang turut mendukung penanganan kesehatan didaerah tersebut. Entah kenapa media asing jika dilibatkan langsung tidak pernah objektif, sebaliknya terlihat ada kepentingan dibalik setiap pemberitaannya. Sangat disayangkan jika nilai-nilai jurnalistik yang harusnya mendorong adanya kebenaran selalu dicemarkan oleh wartawan dan media kepentingan sekelas BBC. (@liputankhusus) BERSAMA RAKYAT TNI KUAT #TNI#militerindonesia #military #militer #indonesia #kostrad #tniad #tniau#tnial #pasukankhusus #komando #komandoindonesia #marinir#paskhas #denjaka #denbravo #taifib #terjunpayung #para #pararaider#merdeka #nkri #kopassus #strong #kopaska #indonesiamilitary#photographer #photo #army #indonesianarmy

The AJI said that Henschke and her two co-reporters, Dwiki and Affan, were investigated by the police because of the tweets on Friday, and banned from reporting in Papua since then. The three of them were sent back to Jakarta.
“We condemn the expulsion of the BBC journalists. The incident shows that the government is afraid of foreign reporting of the conditions in Papua,” AJI chairman Abdul Manan said on Saturday.
He said he regretted the fact that the Twitter posts were cited as the reason for expelling the journalists from Papua and not administrative violations.
President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo, he said, had repeatedly stated his commitment to open Papua for foreign journalists. “[This] shows the government is not serious about its promise to open journalistic access to Papua.” (gis/ahw)


2) Asian rights body calls for more action by Jakarta over Papuan health crisis

The Asian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) has called for more action about the health crisis facing Asmat regency in Indonesian-ruled Papua.
The commission has blamed the Indonesian government “for this considerable loss of life”.
“The current efforts to address the problem are simply too little, too late,” it said in a statement from Hongkong.
So far, 68 children have died from measles and serious malnutrition in Asmat.
As reported by national media in Indonesia, the measles and malnutrition epidemic has affected 11 districts of Asmat regency: Swator, Aswi, Akat, Fayit, Pulau Tiga, Kolf Branza, Jetsy, Pantai Kasuari, Safan, Unirsarau, and Siret.
“Being the most remote areas of Asmat regency, victims in these districts have faced serious difficulties in obtaining access to medical facilities,” the AHRC statement said.
“Even in the regency’s capital, Agats, the Agats General Hospital (RSUD) is not equipped to deal with all the patients of measles and malnutrition.”
Patients in church
A category D hospital with limited facilities, paramedics and doctors, the hospital at present needed more medicine due to limited stock, and due to limited space, some patients have been hospitalised in the nearest church building, the AHRC statement said.
This circumstance showed how Papua had been left behind in terms of health facilities, infrastructure and development.
In Jakarta, Java island or other islands such as Sumatra and Bali, there were numerous public and private hospitals of type B and A, easy to access, the statement said.
Papua mostly has public hospitals of type D, especially in remote areas. There is a category A hospital in Jayapura city, the capital of Papua, but it is quite far from Agats and to reach Jayapura from Agats is not easy due to the lack of infrastructure.
“This situation clearly highlights how neither the central government of Indonesia in Jakarta, nor the local government in Papua province and Asmat regency have been able to develop an early warning system to prevent measles and malnutrition.”

The AHRC said it was concerned that the epidemic could easily spread to other places in Papua, particularly in remote areas lacking in health facilities.
Since Papua was integrated into the Republic of Indonesia in 1969, Papua has remained the poorest and least developed province.
Citizens’ rightsAs a state party to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Indonesia was obligated to:
  • ensure its citizens’ rights to be free from hunger;
  • address the prevention, treatment and control of epidemic, endemic, occupational and other diseases; and
  • create conditions which would assure medical attention to all.
Similarly, national laws such as Law No. 36 of 2009 guaranteed the right to equal health access for all citizens, the AHRC said.
The commission said it viewed the current lack of health access and facilities in Papua – and the deaths of 68 children – as a clear violation of the Indonesian government’s responsibility towards its citizens.
“By not developing equal health care in Papua, the government is to blame for this considerable loss of life. The current efforts to address the problem are simply too little, too late,” the statement said.
The AHRC said the government should immediately announce a health emergency in Papua and open access for medical aid, including international medical support. It should also allow access to the media to ensure accountability and to monitor the eradication of the epidemic.
The government also needed an affirmative action policy to boost development of health access in Papua.
Priority for Papua
The assistance from the central government should not merely be limited to eradicating disease in Asmat regency, but should ensure that remote areas in Papua received priority in development of health access, facilities and infrastructure, the statement said.
The National Commission on Human Rights (Komnas HAM), the Minister of Health and Ombudsman of Republic of Indonesia, the House of Representatives, in particular Commission IX which concerns health, food and medicines, should take initiatives to monitor, evaluate and ensure the implementation of such policies, the AHRC said.
Local government should also open access for NGOs and media to monitor the recovery and development in remote areas.
The AHRC also urged the government to comprehensively ensure that all children, including pregnant mothers in Papua, particularly in Asmat regency, were given enough nutrition, food, and vaccines to prevent disease.

No comments:

Post a Comment