2) Melanesia Media Freedom Forum outcome statement declaration
------------------------
1) Lawyers protest limited access to Surya Anta, other Papua treason suspects
CNN Indonesia – November 12, 2019
Indonesian People's Front for West Papua spokesperson Surya Anta (Metro Jaya police
Jakarta – The Papua Advocacy Team has protested the continued restrictions on access to six Papua activists who are being detained at the Mobile Brigade Command Headquarters (Mako Brimob) detention centre in Depok.
The six activists, Paulus Surya Anta Ginting, Anes Tabuni, Charles Kossay, Ambrosius Mulait, Isay Wenda and Arina Elopere have been charged by police under the makar(treason, subversion, rebellion) articles.
Because of this, the advocacy team is asking that police investigators allow access for their lawyers to meet with their clients at the detention centre at any time.
“Our legal teams still aren’t able to enter 24 hours a day to meet with our clients. Now, because of this we are asking the police investigators for access for lawyers to be given an exemption to enter the Mako Brimob”, said Papua Advocacy Team member Michael Himan following a pre-trial hearing challenging the activists arrest at the South Jakarta District Court on Monday November 11.
These restrictions on access has made it difficult for lawyers to communicate and as a consequence, said Himan, they are unable to directly monitor the conditions of their respective clients. This was the case for example when one of the detainees, Arina Elopere, was suffering psychological problems which have still not been treated.
“There has also still been no response [on the request for medical staff]”, said Mike – as Himan is known by his friends.
Elopere is said to be suffering shortness of breath and has begun to hallucinate due to his psychological condition. Elopere is the only occupant in a large cell located far from his other friends.
Two other of his clients meanwhile, Ambrosius Mulait and Dano (Anes) Tabuni are also dealing with health issues. “One of Ambros[ius]’ teeth had to be pulled out”, said Papua Advocacy Team member Oky Wiratama.
Wiratama is also questioning the grounds for the visitation restrictions because according to the Criminal Procedural Code (KUHAP), lawyers should be able to visit their clients at any time.
“But in this case, we as lawyers have been restricted to only two visits a week, Tuesdays and Fridays”, said Wiratama.
Wiratama said that police are justifying the restrictions based on a national police chief regulation (Perkapolri) on visits. But, said Wiratama, the regulation only regulates family visits, not lawyers.
“Lawyers cannot be treated the same as family, [other] visitors. In the case of families visits are only allowed on Thursdays and Fridays, but lawyers must be allowed [to visit] 1x24 hours”, said Wiratama.
“Under the Perkapolri it does indeed explain about visiting detainees, for families it is indeed explained, but for lawyers we use the KUHAP, where there are no restrictions on lawyers, they can [visit] anytime”, he added again.
Article 69 of the KUHAP on legal aid stipulates that lawyers are entitled to accompany suspects from the moment they are arrested or detained and though all stages of the investigation.
Meanwhile there are exceptions in cases of crimes against state security which are regulated under Article 71 Paragraph 2, which give officials the authority to listen in to discussions between lawyers and suspects. Despite this, lawyers are still able to communicate with suspects. (ika/pmg)
[Translated by James Balowski. The original title of the article was “Tim Advokasi Papua Minta Diberi Akses Temui Surya Anta Cs”.]
——————————————
2) Melanesia Media Freedom Forum outcome statement declaration
| 9:01 pm GMT+12, 13/11/2019, Australia |
We, the participants at the Melanesian Media Freedom representing media from Fiji, Vanuatu, Solomon Islands, Papua New Guinea and West Papua, wish to express concern about growing threats to media freedom in our region and call on members of our industry and other organisations and individuals to act to help secure the future of the fourth estate as a vital pillar of democracy.
Professional media, through accurate and impartial reporting has a crucial role to play. As António Guterres, United Nations Secretary-General, said on World Press Freedom Day 2019:
"No democracy is complete without access to transparent and reliable information. It is the cornerstone for building fair and impartial institutions, holding leaders accountable and speaking truth to power."
We note that Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights states: “Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers”.
In this context we observe that
- A better understanding is needed of the role of journalism in Melanesian democracies. Awareness of the accountability role played by journalists and the need for them to be able to exercise their professional skills without fear is critical to the functioning of our democracies.
- The media is ready to work with all parties that want to improve the social media landscape: There is an urgent need to for the media to assert its role as a source of accurate and impartial information and to play a role in building social media literacy and public understanding of how to identify credible sources of information.
We express concern that
- The range of threats to media freedom is increasing. These include restrictive legislation, intimidation, political threats, legal threats and prosecutions, assaults and police and military brutality, illegal detention, online abuse, racism between ethnic groups and the ever-present threats facing particularly younger and female reporters who may face violence both on the job and within their own homes.
- Threats to media freedom are having professional, personal and health impacts on journalists across Melanesia. The situation in West Papua is of particular concern with attacks on journalists resulting in deaths and injuries.
- The unwillingness of politicians and officials to engage in dialogue is undermining the media’s accountability role: public figures are becoming more resistant to responding to direct questions from media, choosing instead to issue media releases, or statements on social media or to preferred media outlets. In addition to undermining the crucial accountability role of the media, this places broadcast media (which requires actuality) at a disadvantage.
- Obstruction from development partners and communications consultants, including from Australia, are in some instances contributing to problems of lack of access to decision-makers.
- The global decline of democracy is making it easier for our governments to silence the media. It is expected this will become a bigger challenge in the future if it is not addressed, as national leaders, media organisations and journalists come under pressure and misinformation campaigns continue.
- Misinformation, propaganda and fake news are a growing problem: there is widespread concern around misinformation and offensive material being posted on social media platforms, sometimes by anonymous sources, some of them state and politically-partisan actors. The media’s role as an antidote, and as a balancing source of verified information is under-recognised and under-supported.
- Social media is an existential threat undermining Melanesian media companies: the erosion of editorial budgets and vulnerability of the mainstream media’s business model to the flight of advertising revenue and audiences to social media is an urgent threat to media throughout Melanesia and therefore to media freedom.
- Significant sections of the population in some Melanesian countries do not have access to information services. This undermines the media’s role in providing access to information and debate. Some media organisations, including public broadcasters, lack the basic equipment needed to do their job properly.
- Women in the media face additional challenges. Women are underrepresented in many newsrooms and in media management. They can face additional challenges in being recognised and responded to by people in authority and they face threats to their safety including sexual harassment, gender-based violence and expectations from partners and family.
We applaud
- The invaluable work of National Media Organisations, the Pacific Islands News Association (PINA), the Pacific Freedom Forum (PFF), and the Pacific Media Watch Freedom Project (based at the AUT’s Pacific Media Centre) in defending media freedom (including at IFEX).
Recommendations
We call on Melanesian governments to
• Respect the media and its necessary place in national conversations.
• Require political leaders and senior public servants make themselves available for interviews with their local media.
• Recognise, respect and support National Media Associations as the voice of the media industry.
• Fund public broadcasters properly to ensure they have sufficient equipment and staff to enable their services to reach all citizens in their country and to adequately play their watch-dog role.
• Assure the safety of journalists as they pursue their professional activities.
We call on the Papua New Guinea government to
• Respect the independence of media institutions and journalists.
• Strengthen anti-corruption and whistle-blower protection legislation to include journalists and media practitioners.
We call on civic institutions in Bougainville to
• Respect and respond promptly to requests for information at this crucial time.
We call on the Vanuatu government to
• Uphold the appeal of the Daily Post against the rejection of Dan McGarry’s work permit. He has been forced to resign as media director at the Daily Post/BuzzFM.
• End its attacks against the Media Association of Vanuatu, which is the recognised voice of the media industry.
We call on the Fiji government to
• Repeal the media decree. The draconian penalties and the vagueness of offences it establishes are having a stifling effect on free media.
We call on the Premier of Western Province in Solomon Islands to
• End his threats to legitimate news organisations.
We call on the Indonesian government to
• Stop killing and criminalising journalists
• Allow access to foreign journalists, parliamentarians and independent observers to West Papua.
• Investigate and bring to justice those responsible for attacks on journalists.
• End state-sponsored misinformation and disinformation about West Papua
• Stop the racist stigmatisation of indigenous West Papuan journalists.
We call on all development partners and the international community to
• Recognise and advocate for the role of the free and independent media as an essential accountability institution in Melanesia.
• Act as role models by allowing their own free and independent media to thrive.
• Make representatives available for interviews with Melanesian media.
• Recognise and support National and Regional Media Associations as the voice of the media industry, including through funding to enable them to develop policy and action.
• Provide institutional support for National Media Associations to assist them to strengthen their collective voice and to provide training and mentoring.
• Continue with capacity-strengthening work with media including to assist their business-models navigate the flight of advertising revenue to social media.
• Facilitate linkages between Melanesian media organisations and those in the developed world.
As participants in the Melanesian Media Freedom Forum we commit to
• Establish a network to assist participants to respond promptly and effectively to threats to journalist safety or to media freedom.
• Expand our reach to include Kanaky.
• Advocate for funding to enable National and Regional media organisations to respond to issues
• Pursue content-sharing between our organisations and, in particular to improve awareness about issues in Bougainville and West Papua.
• Work constructively with all our media networks in Melanesia, the Pacific and beyond.
Who are we:
The Melanesia Media Freedom Forum (MMFF) was developed to respond to increasing media repression in Melanesia and to increase trans-national regional co-operation and knowledge-sharing among Melanesian journalists, editors, publishers, press-freedom advocates and journalism scholars. The industry stream of the Forum brought together 13 leading media practitioners from Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands, Vanuatu, Fiji and West Papua for two days of discussions in a safe neutral venue under the Chatham house rule. To facilitate frank discussions journalists participated in their personal capacity not in the name of their media organisations. This statement is issued by those journalists. The Pacific Islands News Association and the Pacific Freedom Forum were represented at the highest level.
The MMFF thanks the following organisations for their contribution to travel and other support: Griffith University, MEAA, The British High Commission Suva, TNC Pacific Consulting, the University of Melbourne, Women in Media and Auckland University of Technology Pacific Media Centre and Pacific Media Watch
The Melanesian Media Freedom Forum was held from 11-12th November 2019 at Griffith University, Southbank, Brisbane.
Media Contacts: Scott Waide, Papua New Guinea Ph: +675 7030 0459 Email: scott.waide@gmail.com
Samisoni Pareti, Fiji Ph: +679 747 2658 Email: paretis@gmail.com
SOURCE: MMF/PACNEWS
Professional media, through accurate and impartial reporting has a crucial role to play. As António Guterres, United Nations Secretary-General, said on World Press Freedom Day 2019:
"No democracy is complete without access to transparent and reliable information. It is the cornerstone for building fair and impartial institutions, holding leaders accountable and speaking truth to power."
We note that Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights states: “Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers”.
In this context we observe that
- A better understanding is needed of the role of journalism in Melanesian democracies. Awareness of the accountability role played by journalists and the need for them to be able to exercise their professional skills without fear is critical to the functioning of our democracies.
- The media is ready to work with all parties that want to improve the social media landscape: There is an urgent need to for the media to assert its role as a source of accurate and impartial information and to play a role in building social media literacy and public understanding of how to identify credible sources of information.
We express concern that
- The range of threats to media freedom is increasing. These include restrictive legislation, intimidation, political threats, legal threats and prosecutions, assaults and police and military brutality, illegal detention, online abuse, racism between ethnic groups and the ever-present threats facing particularly younger and female reporters who may face violence both on the job and within their own homes.
- Threats to media freedom are having professional, personal and health impacts on journalists across Melanesia. The situation in West Papua is of particular concern with attacks on journalists resulting in deaths and injuries.
- The unwillingness of politicians and officials to engage in dialogue is undermining the media’s accountability role: public figures are becoming more resistant to responding to direct questions from media, choosing instead to issue media releases, or statements on social media or to preferred media outlets. In addition to undermining the crucial accountability role of the media, this places broadcast media (which requires actuality) at a disadvantage.
- Obstruction from development partners and communications consultants, including from Australia, are in some instances contributing to problems of lack of access to decision-makers.
- The global decline of democracy is making it easier for our governments to silence the media. It is expected this will become a bigger challenge in the future if it is not addressed, as national leaders, media organisations and journalists come under pressure and misinformation campaigns continue.
- Misinformation, propaganda and fake news are a growing problem: there is widespread concern around misinformation and offensive material being posted on social media platforms, sometimes by anonymous sources, some of them state and politically-partisan actors. The media’s role as an antidote, and as a balancing source of verified information is under-recognised and under-supported.
- Social media is an existential threat undermining Melanesian media companies: the erosion of editorial budgets and vulnerability of the mainstream media’s business model to the flight of advertising revenue and audiences to social media is an urgent threat to media throughout Melanesia and therefore to media freedom.
- Significant sections of the population in some Melanesian countries do not have access to information services. This undermines the media’s role in providing access to information and debate. Some media organisations, including public broadcasters, lack the basic equipment needed to do their job properly.
- Women in the media face additional challenges. Women are underrepresented in many newsrooms and in media management. They can face additional challenges in being recognised and responded to by people in authority and they face threats to their safety including sexual harassment, gender-based violence and expectations from partners and family.
We applaud
- The invaluable work of National Media Organisations, the Pacific Islands News Association (PINA), the Pacific Freedom Forum (PFF), and the Pacific Media Watch Freedom Project (based at the AUT’s Pacific Media Centre) in defending media freedom (including at IFEX).
Recommendations
We call on Melanesian governments to
• Respect the media and its necessary place in national conversations.
• Require political leaders and senior public servants make themselves available for interviews with their local media.
• Recognise, respect and support National Media Associations as the voice of the media industry.
• Fund public broadcasters properly to ensure they have sufficient equipment and staff to enable their services to reach all citizens in their country and to adequately play their watch-dog role.
• Assure the safety of journalists as they pursue their professional activities.
We call on the Papua New Guinea government to
• Respect the independence of media institutions and journalists.
• Strengthen anti-corruption and whistle-blower protection legislation to include journalists and media practitioners.
We call on civic institutions in Bougainville to
• Respect and respond promptly to requests for information at this crucial time.
We call on the Vanuatu government to
• Uphold the appeal of the Daily Post against the rejection of Dan McGarry’s work permit. He has been forced to resign as media director at the Daily Post/BuzzFM.
• End its attacks against the Media Association of Vanuatu, which is the recognised voice of the media industry.
We call on the Fiji government to
• Repeal the media decree. The draconian penalties and the vagueness of offences it establishes are having a stifling effect on free media.
We call on the Premier of Western Province in Solomon Islands to
• End his threats to legitimate news organisations.
We call on the Indonesian government to
• Stop killing and criminalising journalists
• Allow access to foreign journalists, parliamentarians and independent observers to West Papua.
• Investigate and bring to justice those responsible for attacks on journalists.
• End state-sponsored misinformation and disinformation about West Papua
• Stop the racist stigmatisation of indigenous West Papuan journalists.
We call on all development partners and the international community to
• Recognise and advocate for the role of the free and independent media as an essential accountability institution in Melanesia.
• Act as role models by allowing their own free and independent media to thrive.
• Make representatives available for interviews with Melanesian media.
• Recognise and support National and Regional Media Associations as the voice of the media industry, including through funding to enable them to develop policy and action.
• Provide institutional support for National Media Associations to assist them to strengthen their collective voice and to provide training and mentoring.
• Continue with capacity-strengthening work with media including to assist their business-models navigate the flight of advertising revenue to social media.
• Facilitate linkages between Melanesian media organisations and those in the developed world.
As participants in the Melanesian Media Freedom Forum we commit to
• Establish a network to assist participants to respond promptly and effectively to threats to journalist safety or to media freedom.
• Expand our reach to include Kanaky.
• Advocate for funding to enable National and Regional media organisations to respond to issues
• Pursue content-sharing between our organisations and, in particular to improve awareness about issues in Bougainville and West Papua.
• Work constructively with all our media networks in Melanesia, the Pacific and beyond.
Who are we:
The Melanesia Media Freedom Forum (MMFF) was developed to respond to increasing media repression in Melanesia and to increase trans-national regional co-operation and knowledge-sharing among Melanesian journalists, editors, publishers, press-freedom advocates and journalism scholars. The industry stream of the Forum brought together 13 leading media practitioners from Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands, Vanuatu, Fiji and West Papua for two days of discussions in a safe neutral venue under the Chatham house rule. To facilitate frank discussions journalists participated in their personal capacity not in the name of their media organisations. This statement is issued by those journalists. The Pacific Islands News Association and the Pacific Freedom Forum were represented at the highest level.
The MMFF thanks the following organisations for their contribution to travel and other support: Griffith University, MEAA, The British High Commission Suva, TNC Pacific Consulting, the University of Melbourne, Women in Media and Auckland University of Technology Pacific Media Centre and Pacific Media Watch
The Melanesian Media Freedom Forum was held from 11-12th November 2019 at Griffith University, Southbank, Brisbane.
Media Contacts: Scott Waide, Papua New Guinea Ph: +675 7030 0459 Email: scott.waide@gmail.com
Samisoni Pareti, Fiji Ph: +679 747 2658 Email: paretis@gmail.com
SOURCE: MMF/PACNEWS
-------------------
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.