2) Police fail to protect Papuan students during TRIKORA Commemoration in Makassar City, South Sulawesi
----------------------------------------------
Human rights Monitor
1) Military personnel allegedly beat and arbitrarily detain Papuan in Enarotali
On 13 December 2025, at around 4:00 pm, Indonesian military personnel arbitrarily arrested and ill-treated 27-year-old Papuan, Mr Nomianus Nabelau, in Enarotali Town, Paniai Regency, Central Papua Province. The soldiers accused Mr Nabealau of being affiliated with the West Papua National Liberation Army (TPNPB) without substantiated grounds. Mr Nabelau was reportedly ill-treated during arrest and questioning, resulting in facial swelling and other injuries (see photo on top, source: independent HRD). He was released the same day after authorities found no evidence to support the allegation.
According to information received, the incident began when military personnel apprehended Mr Nomianus Nabelau in the centre of Enarotali City. During the arrest, he was physically assaulted, including repeated blows and kicks. Military personnel then interrogated him under coercive conditions. After the interrogation, the authorities reportedly acknowledged the absence of proof linking him to the TPNPB and released him later that day. Following the incident, Mr Nabelau sought medical treatment in the Youtadi Village.
Human rights analysis
This incident raises serious concerns of arbitrary deprivation of liberty and ill-treatment by state agents. Under international human rights law, the State must ensure that any arrest is lawful, necessary, proportionate, and non-discriminatory, and that all detainees are protected from torture and other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment. The violent apprehension based on an unverified accusation, followed by coercive interrogation and release without charge, indicates a pattern of repressive security practices rather than lawful law enforcement. Where the use of force accompanies arrest, it must be strictly limited to what is necessary. The allegations described are incompatible with those standards.
The case also engages Indonesia’s obligations to provide effective remedies. Where credible allegations of abuse by military personnel exist, the State is required to carry out a prompt, impartial, independent, and effective investigation, ensure victim protection, and pursue accountability through processes capable of identifying perpetrators and leading to appropriate sanctions. Medical documentation of injuries and timely witness protection are particularly important to prevent intimidation and to preserve evidence. Failure to investigate and prosecute such abuses entrenches impunity and increases the risk of recurrence against other civilians in the Papuan provinces.
Detailed Case Data
Location: Enarotali, Paniai Timur, Paniai Regency, Central Papua, Indonesia (-3.9264917, 136.3648679)
Region: Indonesia, Central Papua, Paniai, East Paniai
Total number of victims: 1
Location: Enarotali, Paniai Timur, Paniai Regency, Central Papua, Indonesia (-3.9264917, 136.3648679)
Region: Indonesia, Central Papua, Paniai, East Paniai
Total number of victims: 1
| # | Number of Victims | Name, Details | Gender | Age | Group Affiliation | Violations |
| 1. | 1 | Nomianus Nabelau | male | 27 | Indigenous Peoples | arbitrary detention, ill-treatment |
Perpetrator: , Indonesian Military (TNI)
Issues: indigenous peoples
——————————————————
Human rights Monitor
2) Police fail to protect Papuan students during TRIKORA Commemoration in Makassar City, South Sulawesi
On 19 December 2025, Papuan students in Makassar City, South Sulawesi province, carried out a peaceful demonstration in commemoration of the TRIKORA Military Operation, which took place on 19 December 1961. The protesters dispersed after being attacked by nationalist mass organisations and facing repressive police response, including the firing of tear gas in front of and into the Papuan student dormitory where protesters had sought safety. The incident allegedly resulted in respiratory distress for several participants and head lacerations for two others, raising serious concerns of ill-treatment and the broader suppression of freedom of expression and peaceful assembly.
According to information received, participants first consolidated at designated meeting points, including the Yalimo Dormitory, Timika Dormitory, and Intan Jaya Dormitory, before walking towards the Mandala Monument of West Irian Liberation at around 09:00 am. Protesters reportedly arrived at 09:49 am and commenced the commemoration peacefully at 10:00 am. Approximately thirty minutes later, a group described as a reactionary mass organisation allegedly approached the demonstration, forcibly pulled the command rope until it broke, attempted to seize banners, and confiscated items including megaphones. An altercation reportedly followed, involving shoving between protesters and members of the mass organisation.
At approximately 10:42 am, protesters were reportedly compelled to retreat from the protest site together with police officers and return to the Kamasan IV Makassar Papua Men’s Dormitory area. The police reportedly prepared a police truck and transported protesters at 11:02 am, arriving at the dormitory at 11:09 am. Upon arrival, protesters demanded that police secure the return of protest equipment allegedly confiscated by the mass organisation, stating they would continue protesting outside the dormitory if the items were not returned.
Tensions escalated at approximately 1:00 pm, amid allegations that police were not taking adequate steps to fulfil their protective duties. Protesters allege that police officers acted as bystanders without protecting the crowd. It is reported that stone-throwing escalated between protesters and members of the mass organisation. Police subsequently fired tear gas at protesters both in front of and inside the dormitory area.
Several protesters reportedly experienced respiratory problems after exposure to tear gas, and at least two sustained head lacerations during the violence. Shortly after the incident, protesters retreated into the dormitory. Further negotiations reportedly resumed at 3:00 pm, during which police stated they would guarantee the safety of individuals leaving to return home or shop and would retreat a few steps away from the dormitory area.
Human rights analysis
This incident raises serious concerns under international human rights law and Indonesia’s obligations to respect, protect, and fulfil fundamental freedoms. The commemoration of TRIKORA constitutes a form of political expression and assembly protected by the rights to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly under Articles 19 and 21 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). Any restriction must be lawful, necessary, and proportionate. Reports that the assembly began peacefully, followed by interference and confiscation by a non-state group, indicate that the authorities had a duty to protect participants from violence by third parties, prevent escalation, and ensure that individuals could exercise their rights without intimidation. The reported failure to prevent or respond effectively to the seizure of protest equipment and physical intimidation by the mass organisation suggests a potential breach of the State’s positive obligations to protect demonstrators.
The subsequent police response, including the deployment of tear gas into the dormitory area where protesters were concentrated, raises substantial concerns regarding necessity, proportionality, and precaution. The use of tear gas in or near enclosed residential spaces foreseeably increases the risk of serious health impacts, particularly for individuals with respiratory vulnerabilities. The reported injuries and respiratory distress may amount to ill-treatment, depending on severity, intent, purpose, and the manner of deployment.
Authorities should provide clear guarantees of non-repetition, including operational measures that prioritise facilitation of peaceful assemblies, timely intervention against violence by non-state actors, and strict limitations on tear gas use consistent with human rights standards. Protective measures should also be adopted to ensure Papuan students in Makassar can exercise their rights without intimidation, harassment, or reprisals.
Table of victims
| No. | Name | Description |
| 1 | Novita Telenggen | Respiratory problems reportedly caused by tear gas exposure |
| 2 | Anteks Tekege | Respiratory problems reportedly caused by tear gas exposure |
| 3 | Dasman Wenda | Respiratory problems reportedly caused by tear gas exposure, and Head laceration reportedly sustained during escalation/stone-throwing |
| 4 | Rotalina Gwijangge | Respiratory problems reportedly caused by tear gas exposure |
| 5 | Kolepian Numan | Respiratory problems reportedly caused by tear gas exposure |
| 6 | Narelak Lilbib | Head laceration reportedly sustained during escalation/stone-throwinM |
Members of nationalist reactionary groups attack Papuan students in Makassar on 19 December 2025
(Photos/video)
Detailed Case Data
Location: Makassar, Makassar City, South Sulawesi, Indonesia (-5.1615828, 119.4359281) Mandala Monument for Papuan Liberation
Region: Indonesia, South Sulawesi, Makassar
Total number of victims: 6
Location: Makassar, Makassar City, South Sulawesi, Indonesia (-5.1615828, 119.4359281) Mandala Monument for Papuan Liberation
Region: Indonesia, South Sulawesi, Makassar
Total number of victims: 6
| # | Number of Victims | Name, Details | Gender | Age | Group Affiliation | Violations |
| 1. | 1 | Novita Telenggen | female | adult | Student | |
| 2. | 1 | Anteks tekege | male | adult | Student | |
| 3. | 1 | Rotalina Gwijangge | female | adult | Student | |
| 4. | 1 | Dasman Wenda | male | adult | Student | |
| 5. | 1 | Kolepian Numan | male | adult | Student | |
| 6. | 1 | Narelak Lilbib | male | adult | Student |
Perpetrator: POLRES
Perpetrator details: Polres Makassar members
Issues: indigenous peoples-------------------------------
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.