1) Journalists
Origin France "secured" in Papua Police
2) Indonesian
authorities arrest French journalist in West Papua in the company of
separatists
3) Papua Police: French
Journalist, Three Separatists Arrested
4)
Papua Police Arrest French Journalist, Separatists
5) French journalist interrogated by police in Papua
6)
ESDM Can Hold Export Permit for Freeport
7) Dams, Dam
Lies and Corruption
8) Statement
by Executive Director of LP3BH
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A google translate of article in suarapapua.com. Be-aware google translate can be a bit erratic.
Original bahasda link at
http://suarapapua.com/read/2014/08/07/1597/jurnalis-asal-perancis-“diamankan”-di-polda-papua-
1) Journalists Origin France "secured" in Papua Police
By: Oktovianus Pogau | Thursday, August 7, 2014 - 9:06 pm | Viewed: 518 times
Journalists Origin France "secured" in Papua Police
Two French TV journalist arrested in Jayapura in 2010 (Photo: Ist)
PAPUAN, Jayapura - Police (Police) of Papua, on Thursday (06/8/2014) night, securing a French journalist, Thomas Charles (40), who allegedly was to cover what Jayawijaya, Papua Province.
Wamena police chief, Chief. Adolof Beay when confirmed suarapapua.com, from Jayapura, this afternoon, confirmed the information.
"He's on a tourist visa, but it does work, so we secured him. Initially admitted as a tourist, but later admitted also as a journalist, "said Chief of Police.
Further police chief, reporter in question has now secured in the Papua Regional Police Headquarters, and was asked for information related to its activities in Papua.
"It could immediately ask the Papua Police. Because the question already secured in Jayapura since noon, "he said.
According to the police chief, the police secure the concerned while riding a motorcycle with the local community.
"We've watched since the beginning, and was arrested while riding a motorcycle with the local community," said Chief of Police.
Just a note, any journalist who wants to cover what Papua should get permission from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
Oktovianus POGAU
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.smh.com.au/world/indonesian-authorities-arrest-french-journalist-in-west-papua-in-the-company-of-separatists-20140808-101pum.html
2) Indonesian authorities arrest French journalist in West Papua in the company of separatists
This file photo shows a West Papuan separatist carrying the banned Morning Star flag as he walks past a line of Indonesian riot police officers surrounding a pro-independence celebration in Jayapura, Irian Jaya. Photo: AP
A western journalist has been arrested and jailed in West Papua, underlining the tough approach that Indonesian authorities still take to media scrutiny in the restive region.
The police chief of the Lany Jaya area, senior commissioner Adolf Beyage, confirmed to Fairfax Media that his officers had detained Thomas Charles Tendeis, who he said was a French journalist.
“He was using a tourist visa but in fact he was doing journalistic work,” Mr Lanny said.
The Papuan police spokesman, Senior Commissioner Sulistyo Pudjo, later said Mr Tendeis, 40, was arrested on Wednesday in the company of three members of separatist organisations.
“We’ll work out which laws should be used to charge [the suspects] — the Press Law, the Criminal Code, the Immigration Law or something else.”“We were worried that his activities here were part of an effort to destabilise Papua,” Mr Pudjo said.
Western reporters wanting to work in Indonesia must have a journalists’ visa, but to work in the Papua and West Papua provinces they must gain another, hard-to-get permission form signed off by the gamut of Indonesian government authorities, including police and military.
Indonesia is highly sensitive about the state of the poverty-stricken Papua and West Papua provinces, which have hosted a long-running but low-level separatist insurgency, as well as intractable poverty, social and environmental issues.
Police often argue that journalists are denied permission to enter for their own security.
Comment has been sought from the French embassy.
Jayapura. Papua Police say they have arrested three members of the Free Papua Organization (OPM) and a French journalist in their company on Wednesday.
“A foreign journalist, from France, was arrested in Wamena on Wednesday,” Papua Police spokesman Sr. Comr. Pudjo Sulistyo said on Thursday. “He came to Papua as a tourist but was carrying out illegal reporting activities.”
The Frenchman was identified by police as 40-year-old Thomas Charles Tendeis. He was arrested in Lany Jaya district along with the three suspected separatists, identified as L.K., D.D. and J.W. Their separatist group was supposedly led by Enden Wanimbo.
“We’re worried that his [Tendeis] activities here were part of an effort to destabilize Papua,” Pudjo said, adding that police knew Tendeis had contacted Enden and Puron Wenda, another separatist leader.
The Indonesian government does not allow foreign journalists to carry out reporting duties in Papua, the scene of a decades-long, low-level insurgency.
“We will study the laws which will be used to charge [the suspects], whether it’s the Press Law, the Criminal Code, the Immigration Law or something else,” Pudjo said.
He added that the Frenchman was on his way to Puncak Jaya from Wamena at the time of his arrest.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FRIDAY, 08 AUGUST, 2014 | 00:48 WIB
4) Papua Police Arrest French Journalist, Separatists
TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - French journalist Tendeis Charles Thomas, 40, was arrested by the Jayawijaya Police in Wamena, Papua, on Thursday morning, August 7. Tendeis was captured along with three suspected separatists, whose group is supposedly led by Puron Wenda and Enden Wanimbo. Wenda and Wanimbo have long been suspected as gunmen operating in Papua's highlands.
"Tendeis was arrested at Hotel Mas Budi, Wamena, Jayawijaya, with three of Enden Wanimbo and Wenda Puron's men," Papua Police spokesman Sr. Comr. Pudjo Sulistyo told reporters on Thursday.
The three separatist suspects, 24 years old JW, LK (17), and DD (27), said Pudjo, came from Lanny Jaya district.
Pudjo said Tendeis violated his visa permit as written in his passport. "His visa stated that his visit to Wamena was as a tourist visa, but was carrying out illegal reporting activities."
"Until now, both foreign and NGO journalists are still banned by the central government from doing report or research activities in Papua," said Pudjo, who said he fears that these activities are engineered to create chaos.
Pudjo said the Frenchman and the three separatist suspects will be taken to Jayapura on Friday morning for further investigation.
"We are still mulling on what laws will be used to charge the suspects, whether it's the Press Law, the Criminal Code, the Immigration Law or something else," Pudjo said.
CUNDING LEVI
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5) French journalist interrogated by police in Papua
Kamis, 7 Agustus 2014 22:55 WIB | 315 Views
Jayapura, Papua (ANTARA News) - A French journalist had been interrogated by police in Papua after conducting a journalistic work without permit in a sensitive area where shooting incidents had recently occurred.
Charles Thomas Tendeis (40) was interrogated at the regional police command headquarters in Jayapura on Thursday after he was caught covering a shooting incident-prone area.
"He has been detained at the Regional Police Command Headquarters for interrogation, but where it will lead to is up to the police," Jayawijaya police resort chief Adjunct Senior Commissioner Adolf Beay said when asked for his confirmation about the incident.
He said the French journalist was arrested in an area in Wamena in the district of Jayawijaya on Wednesday night while riding on a motorcycle with a local resident.
"Initially, he claimed he was a tourist, but after further questioning he finally admitted that he was a journalist. He, meanwhile, has a tourist visa," he said.
Papua regional police command spokesman Senior Commissioner Sulistyo Pudjo, meanwhile, declined to explain the case in detail when asked for his confirmation on the issue on a separate occasion.
However, he confirmed that the French journalist had been detained by the police.
"That is true. He is believed to have tried to contact a criminal armed group there," he added.(*)
Charles Thomas Tendeis (40) was interrogated at the regional police command headquarters in Jayapura on Thursday after he was caught covering a shooting incident-prone area.
"He has been detained at the Regional Police Command Headquarters for interrogation, but where it will lead to is up to the police," Jayawijaya police resort chief Adjunct Senior Commissioner Adolf Beay said when asked for his confirmation about the incident.
He said the French journalist was arrested in an area in Wamena in the district of Jayawijaya on Wednesday night while riding on a motorcycle with a local resident.
"Initially, he claimed he was a tourist, but after further questioning he finally admitted that he was a journalist. He, meanwhile, has a tourist visa," he said.
Papua regional police command spokesman Senior Commissioner Sulistyo Pudjo, meanwhile, declined to explain the case in detail when asked for his confirmation on the issue on a separate occasion.
However, he confirmed that the French journalist had been detained by the police.
"That is true. He is believed to have tried to contact a criminal armed group there," he added.(*)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
THURSDAY, 07 AUGUST, 2014 | 19:04 WIB
6) ESDM Can Hold Export Permit for Freeport
TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - The Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) Ministry will continue to monitor mineral export volume shipped by PT Freeport Indonesia. If the volume is less than 60 percent of 750,000 tons a year, the ESDM ministry may halt Freeport’s export activities.
“The concentrate export can be stopped so it can be improved,” Sukhyar, the mineral and coal director general at the ESDM Ministry, said at his office on Thursday, August 07, 2014.
Sukhyar said this move was part of the government’s efforts to keep an eye on Freeport’s activities after the renegotiation agreement between Freeport and the government was signed. He added after the deal was secured, Freeport would hold an export permit (SPE) issued by the Trade Ministry.
“If they are willing to follow the rules, we will reduce the tariff. If they perform poorly, we won’t grant them the permit,” Sukhyar said.
Responding to the question on contract amendment by the new government, Sukhyar said it was possible. After the signing of a memorandum of understanding, Sukhyar added, the new government would settle the contract amendment.
PUTRI ADITYOWATI
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
7) Dams, Dam Lies and Corruption
The former Governor of Papua Province, Barnabas Suebu, was charged with corruption on Tuesday (5/8), with accusations relating to funds allocated for an engineering study into a controversial dam in West Papua. Indonesia’s Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK), which was investigating the case, claimed that the state had lost out to the tune of 36 billion Rupiah.
The former governor was accused of abusing his authority in appointing subcontractors to carry out studies into the dam. He is alleged to have links with one of the companies appointed, PT Konsultasi Pembangunan Irian Jaya (PT KPIJ). The executive director of that company and the former head of the Papua Provincial Mining and Energy Office were also charged.
This will be no great surprise to many in Papua as accusations of corruption connected to dam projects in Papua have been circulating for a few years already. Papuan newsletter Tabloid Jubi explained on Tuesday that large sums of money had been allocated from the provincial budget in 2009 and 2010 for ‘Detailed Engineering Design’ studies for dams on the Mamboramo River, in the northern part of Papua, and Umumuka River (or Yawei River as it is known in its upper reaches), which flows from lake Paniai in the highlands to the coast near Timika.
Once the studies were finished, the Jubi article explains, experts from the Agency for the Assessment and Application of Technology judged the results to be too general, insufficiently focussed on establishing the desired objectives and containing inappropriate or incomplete reports. The output of the studies could not be used to put the projects out to tender. The final report for stage one of the Mamberamo project consisted only of images of the basic plan for the Urumuka Hydropower station (yes you did read that correctly, not the Mamberamo project). The experts concluded that PT KPIJ and PT GA which had carried out the studies did not deserve to be paid.
That issue is now in the hands of the justice system. But what about the dams in question? Are they realistically likely to go ahead, or are they just an excuse for top officials to steal state funds with the excuse of planning a mega project?
Both the Mamberamo and the Urumuka dams would be highly destructive if they ever did get built. The Mamberamo river drains most of West Papua that lies north of the Central Mountains. Unbridged, and with only a few villages along its banks as it meanders for 670 kilometers through the rainforest, it is almost certainly the wildest river in the whole of Asia. It goes without saying that a dam would be an ecological catastrophe.
There have been plans to dam the Mamberamo River since the mid 1990s, but those plans have never advanced very far. The 1998 economic crisis was probably one reason for this, and now it seems as if corruption may have been another.
The Urumuka dam would be on a much smaller scale, but still has the potential to be quite destructive. In addition to the ecological impacts, it is almost inevitable that such an intrusive development would bring severe problems in an area which is prone to conflict, displacing people and bringing more security forces to the area. Indigenous voices from the Mee people who live in the affected area have made their opposition clear.
It is not entirely clear how serious the plans are for this hydropower project. Several names of Chinese companies have appeared in press and blog articles connected to the Urumuka project over the last few years, but we have not been able to confirm any concrete commitments by private investors. It was alsoreported in 2011 that Freeport would use 200MW of the project’s 300MW generating capacity, and in 2013 that consultants owned by Freeport had conducted a new detailed engineering study, possibly making up for the shortfalls in the previous government-sponsored study.
News media widely reported an announcement in February 2013 by Papuan provincial government expert staff Agus Sumule that it was hoped that the government would soon be able to agree the Environmental Impact Assessment report (AMDAL) for the project. The plan is also listed as an infrastructure project under the auspices of the Master Plan for the Acceleration and Expansion of Indonesia’s Economic Development (MP3EI) which usually means that the government will make every effort to support the project.
The most recent news concerning both dam projects emerged just over a month ago, when Papuan media (Jubi 1 and CePos) reported from an coordinating meeting on investment planning which took place in Jayapura on June 18th 2014 . In this meeting the government presented plans for two new Green Economy Zones on the western shore of Lake Sentani near Jayapura and in Mimika, in addition to the existing Merauke Integrated Food and Energy Estate.
The meeting in the Aston Hotel explained that the Mimika Zone will encompass the Urumuka dam and a cement factory using tailings from the Freeport mine. No explanation was given of the industry which would be developed at the Binggran (or Bonggrang) site near lake Sentani, but the electricity source would be the Mamberamo Hydroelectric Project.
It is hard so see what could possibly be described as ‘Green’ in these ‘Green Economy Zones’. Large hydro schemes have been roundly discredited as an ecologically sustainable energy source, including by the World Commission on Dams, which was set up by the World Bank and IUCN in 1997.
Alternatively, the vast amounts of energy generated by dams on the Mamberamo River (the hydro potential of the watershed has been estimated at 10,476MW) could be used by the aluminium industry, which needs huge amounts of electricity to process bauxite into aluminium. In November last year, Agus Sugiyono of Indonesia’s Agency for the Assessment and Application of Technology wrote a paper examining the viability of using power from the Mamberamo project to power an aluminium smelter based in Sarmi. Mr Sugiyono is a long-term advocate of the Mamboramo dam, who has been promoting the plan since at least 2007.
In summary, although neither the Mamboramo nor the Urumuka projects appears to have gained sufficient traction for work to start in the near future, both remain as real threats to Papuan indigenous people and forests. Ironically, corrupt local politicians who are alleged to have made money on the back of expensive and useless studies may have wasted state money, but their actions have also probably helped to put the brakes on the mania for inappropriate industrial development that continues to be imposed on Papua, largely against the wishes of indigenous Papuans.Here is a translation of Jubi’s report from the meeting on June 18th:
Jayapura and Mimika to be Green Economy Zones
Aside from the Merauke Integrated Food and Energy Estate the Papuan Provincial Government will establish two more green economy districts, in Binggran in Jayapura and in Mimika.“The establishment of these green economy districts is being prepared to maximise industrial activity, exports, imports and other high-value economic activity” said the second assistent regional secretary for Papua, Elia Loupatty, speaking for Papua Governor Lukus Enembe when opening an investment planning coordinating meeting in the Hotel Aston in Jayapura, Papua on Wednesday 18th June.According to Elia, these green economy zones would be pro-environment and would aim to accelerate regional development and be a model for how industrial development, tourism and trade could penetrate the area, creating new jobs.“To form these green zones sufficient infrastructure will be needed, including environmentally-friendly energy,” he said.Alongside this, it would be in accordance with one of the key missions to develop Papua, the acceleration of infrastructure development and connectivity between different zones and regions whilst promoting principles of sustainable developmentTo that end, Elia said, the government is currently continuing to build a toll-road quality ring road from Jayapura to Sentani. “Meanwhile with money from the national budget we are widening Sentani Airport and increasing facilities at Sentani Airport so that it can be used by wide-bodied aircraft by day or night-time. All of this is in the final stages of being built, “ he said.Meanwhile in the energy sector, he continued, the Urumuka Hydroelectric power station has been planned which would be located across four regencies, Mimika, Deyai, Dogiyai and Paniai to support the Mimika green ekonomi zone.Meanwhile for the Bonggrang green economy zone, plans have been drawn up to build hydroelectric power stations on the Mamboramo river. “And in order to make use of mine tailings for the cement industry in Mimika Region a MoU hs been signed with PT Freeport Indonesia to meet Papua’s cement needs”, he said.Elia made clear that the challenges they would face in developing investment and increasing investment appeal in Papua were no small matter. “However, the rich and abundant natural resources can bring confidence and optimism, that the land of Papua will bring opportunities for businesses and investors to invest with enthusiasm and as broadly as possible in Papua”, he said.At the same event the head of Papua Province investment agency, John Way said that he strongly supported the governor’s policy to develop Papua as self-reliant, moving forwards and secure, by preparing capable human resources.“we are ready to launch programs according to the governor’s vision and mission of Papua as moving forwards, self-reliant and secure. What’s more Papua has abundant natural resources. For that reason, we invite investors to invest their assets in Papua,” said John Way. ↩
This entry was posted in Around West Papua and tagged Dams, Hydroelectric power,Mamberamo, PLTA Mamberamo, PLTA Urumuka, Urumuka. Bookmark the permalink. Comments are closed, but you can leave a trackback: Trackback URL.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
8) Statement by Executive Director of LP3BH
In my position as the Executive-Director of the LP3BH - Manokwari,
I wish to convey a message to the newly elected President and
Vice-President of the Republic of Indonesia, urging them to consider
raising the status of the provinces of Papua and West Papua. The
present Special Autonomy status to be lifted to a higher level than
the special autonomy which is now in force.
This is based on stipulations contained in the 1945 Constitution
which provides the lawful basis for this.
The suggestion about having a more broad-based special autonomy in
regions where there a serious level of conflict such as the Land of
Papua was first made by Ali Alatas, the Foreign Minister in his book,
'The Pebble in the Shoe: The Struggle for East Timor' published by
Aksara Karunia in 2006. In his book, Ali Alatas spoke about the
importance of this status for non-state regions such as the former
province of East Timor.
As far as I can see, this also applicable the Land of Papua whose
people are continually being faced with political differences with
regard to their identity and their basic rights so as to be able to
provide the justification for laws regarding their flag and other
regional symbols.
This is very much like what happened with Puerto Rico in Latin
America when their sportsmen and women took part in the Olympiade
with regard the unfurling of their own flag and regional symbols as a
non-state entity.
Indonesia should also be considering the need for broader special
autonomy for non-state regions such as the Land of Papua. A firs step
in this direction would be appointing a special minister of state for
the Land of Papua in the forthcoming cabinet.
As I have already said previously, the tasks of the
Special State Minister for the Land of Papua would encompass such
issues as employing peaceful measures so as to ensure that West Papua
and its people remain an integral part of the Republic of Indonesia.
What this means in that, as soon as possible after installation of
the President and Vice-President in October this year, all non-organic
military personnel from both the army and the police should be
withdrawn from the Land of Papua.
The first step that needs to be taken is to cut back funding in the
budget for such activities as defence and security and using these
resources for humanitarian activities and not get involved in such
things as combating terrorism.
If the newly elected president agrees to appoint a special state
minister for Papua, one of the minister's key tasks should be to
undertake an evaluation of special autonomy for the thirteen years
since Law 21/2001 was enacted, along with the amendments adopted in
Law 35/2008.
This evaluation is extremely important, bearing mind the
provisions of Law 21/2001,and this should also involve the Papuan
people, in particular the indigenous people living in the mountains in
the interior and should include every village and kampung as well as
towns and cities along the coast and across the whole territory from
Sorong and the Raja Ampat Islands to Samaray, the island of Biak and
the Island of Adi.
The other thing that needs to be done is to produce a format and
mechanism for Dialogue between Papua and Indonesia as the peaceful way
of formulating the role of the Land of Papua within the Indonesian
state.
The dialogue should involve all those who are involved in
disputes, such as the Indonesian Army, the Police, the TPN-OPM as well
as political groups that are active inside Papua as well as overseas.
[Translated by Carmel Budiardjo]
Peace.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.